Metal Pans: Safe Food Storage?

Storing food in metal pans is a common practice, but is it safe? The answer is a little complicated. While some metals are considered safe for food storage, others can leach toxins into your food, especially if the pan is scratched or pitted. So, while it might be tempting to pop your metal pan straight into the fridge after cooking, it's important to consider the potential risks to your health and the quality of your food.

Stainless steel is safe for storing food in the short term

Stainless steel is generally safe for storing food in the short term. It is the least reactive of the commonly used metals and is therefore the least likely to leach toxins into your food. However, it is often combined with other metals such as aluminium or copper, which may be more reactive.

According to Dr Simran Saini, a nutritionist at Fortis Hospital in New Delhi, "It is safe to store your fruits and vegetables in stainless steel containers. There is no reaction with fruits and vegetables in these jars or containers."

However, stainless steel is not perfect for storing food. Firstly, it is important to ensure that the container is not scratched, as scratches increase the chance of leaching. Secondly, acidic foods such as tomato sauce, vinegar, or citrus juice can damage stainless steel, as can undissolved salt crystals. Finally, food stored in stainless steel may spoil faster than food stored in more airtight containers. Therefore, it is recommended to seal the top of stainless steel containers with plastic wrap or aluminium foil before placing the lid on the pot.

Aluminium and copper containers should be avoided for storing fruits

Aluminium and copper containers should be avoided when it comes to storing fruits. This is because fruits contain acids that may react with these metals, causing discolouration and leeching.

Dr Simran Saini, a nutritionist at Fortis Hospital in New Delhi, explains that "Aluminium containers [...] have been seen as a relatively unsafe option when pitted against steel containers. Aluminium is highly reactive in nature and may leach into your food." Shilpa Arora, a macrobiotic nutritionist and health practitioner, agrees, stating that "It is not a good idea to use aluminium foil or utensils as it reacts with fruits and vegetables which may not be good for health."

The same logic applies to copper containers. The acid in fruits can cause copper to leach into the food, which can be harmful to health. Copper containers are also unlikely to be airtight, which means the fruit is less likely to stay fresh for long.

Therefore, it is recommended to use containers made with stainless steel for storing fruits, as it is the least reactive and is generally considered safe.

Acidic foods can damage stainless steel

Storing food in metal pots is not recommended as some metals can leach into the food. Leaching happens when metal from the pot interacts with acids in food, which leads to the food being discolored and tainted with metal.

The amount of metal leaching is dependent on several factors, including the grade of stainless steel, cooking time, and cookware usage. For example, longer cooking durations result in higher amounts of metal leaching, with nickel concentrations increasing up to 34-fold and chromium increasing approximately 35-fold after extended cooking times.

Additionally, scratched or pitted stainless steel pots increase the likelihood of leaching. It is recommended to avoid using harsh tools such as wire scrub brushes or metal mesh scrubbers when cleaning stainless steel cookware to prevent scratches and pits.

While stainless steel is considered one of the safest options for food storage, it is important to be mindful of the potential for leaching, especially when cooking acidic foods.

Food in metal pans goes bad faster

It is not recommended to store food in metal pans, as this can cause the food to spoil faster. Metal pans are not generally considered a safe option for food storage, and it is always advised to use containers made of stainless steel or glass.

Firstly, some metals can leach into food, especially if the pan is scratched. This happens when metal from the pan interacts with acids in the food, causing it to become discoloured and tainted with metal. This can be harmful to health, depending on the type of metal and the extent of leaching. For example, aluminium and copper containers are not suitable for storing acidic fruits as they can cause discolouration and leaching.

Secondly, using the lid of a metal pan can cause food to spoil faster than if an airtight covering, such as plastic wrap, is used. This is because the lid is not airtight, and so the food inside can be affected by the surrounding environment. For example, food can take on the smells and tastes of other items in the fridge, and vice versa.

Thirdly, certain metals react with the acids present in some fruits and vegetables, which can pose a risk to digestive health. Low-grade metals, in particular, can contain toxins that leach into food.

Finally, some metals are not suitable for use in the microwave, which limits their use for storing food that needs to be reheated.

Therefore, it is advisable to avoid using metal pans for food storage, especially for long periods, as it can cause food to spoil faster and may also be harmful to health.

Glass or plastic containers are the safest for storing food

Glass or plastic containers are the safest options for storing food. While metal pots are not recommended for storing food, as some metals can leach into the food, glass and plastic containers are non-reactive and safe for food storage.

Glass containers are long-lasting, easy to clean, and eco-friendly. They are made from high-quality glass that is sturdy and durable, withstanding different temperatures and keeping food fresh. Glass is also safe for health, as it has a non-porous surface that doesn't absorb like plastic and can be washed at high temperatures without melting or warping. Additionally, glass tends to hold its shape better, remain clear in colour, and keep the freshness and flavour of food, especially wet ingredients.

Plastic containers, on the other hand, are lightweight, inexpensive, and space-saving. They are easily stackable and can be transported and refilled easily. However, plastic containers can be stained, scratched, and retain previous food odours. They can also warp in the microwave and dishwasher.

When choosing between glass and plastic containers, consider your specific needs and preferences. Glass containers are ideal for those who prioritise durability, longevity, and environmental impact. Plastic containers may be more suitable for dry foods and those who require lightweight and affordable options. Ultimately, both glass and plastic containers offer safe and effective food storage solutions.

Frequently asked questions