Stainless Steel Vs Non-Stick: Which Pan Wins?

Stainless steel or non-stick pans? It's a question that's been asked in kitchens for years. While non-stick pans are great for cooking eggs and pancakes without the need for lots of oil, stainless steel is better for searing meat and achieving that golden-brown colour. Stainless steel is also more durable, can be pre-heated, and is dishwasher-friendly. However, non-stick pans are generally more affordable and are easier to clean by hand. So, which is better? Well, it depends on what you're cooking. A well-equipped kitchen will have both.

Stainless steel is more durable and has a longer lifespan than non-stick pans

Stainless steel is easy to clean and care for, and is typically dishwasher-safe. It is also non-reactive, so it can be used to cook acidic foods without issue. Stainless steel pans can last a lifetime if properly cared for, and some even come with a lifetime warranty.

The durability of stainless steel pans is due in part to their construction. They are often made with a bonded or clad layer of aluminum or copper to improve heat distribution. This construction method is durable and nimble, and is widely considered the gold standard for everyday, functional cookware.

While stainless steel pans are more durable than non-stick pans, they do require more care when cooking. Food is more prone to sticking to stainless steel, and the surface can be difficult to clean if the temperature is not correctly controlled. However, with the proper techniques, such as preheating and seasoning, stainless steel pans can be made almost non-stick.

Non-stick pans are easier to clean

Non-stick pans are designed to be easy to clean. Their non-stick coating prevents food from sticking to the pan, which means that cleaning them is often as simple as wiping them down with a paper towel. In most cases, a quick scrub with mild dish soap and a soft cloth or sponge will be enough to clean non-stick pans.

To ensure that your non-stick pans remain in good condition, it is important to follow a few care guidelines. Firstly, it is recommended to hand wash non-stick pans instead of putting them in the dishwasher, as the high temperatures and detergents used in dishwashers can break down the non-stick surface. Secondly, avoid using abrasive tools such as steel wool, scouring pads, or stiff scrubbing brushes when cleaning non-stick pans, as these can damage the surface. Thirdly, always ensure that your non-stick pan is cooled down before cleaning it. Running a hot pan under cool water can cause thermal shock, potentially warping the pan and damaging the non-stick coating.

For stubborn residue or burnt-on food, you may need to soak the pan in warm, soapy water for a few hours before gently scrubbing it clean. Alternatively, you can create a natural cleaning solution by mixing baking soda with water or olive oil until it forms a paste, and then applying it to the pan. This solution can also be used to remove discolouration from your non-stick pans.

By following these simple steps, you can keep your non-stick pans clean and well-maintained, ensuring they remain a convenient and low-maintenance part of your kitchen.

Stainless steel is better for searing meat

When it comes to cookware, there are a lot of options to choose from. While non-stick pans are popular due to their convenience and ease of use, stainless steel pans offer several advantages, especially when it comes to searing meat. Here are some reasons why stainless steel is better for searing meat:

Achieving the Perfect Sear

The key to a delicious steak is achieving a perfect sear. Stainless steel pans deliver on this front as they allow you to get that beautiful golden-brown crust on your meat. The high heat retention of stainless steel ensures that your steak develops a mouth-watering sear, enhancing both its flavour and appearance.

Even Heat Distribution

Stainless steel pans are known for their even heat distribution, which is crucial when searing meat. This even heating ensures that your steak cooks evenly, preventing unsightly hot spots or undercooked areas. By maintaining a consistent temperature, you can confidently cook your steak to your desired doneness, whether it's rare, medium-rare, or well-done.

Durability

Stainless steel pans are built to last. They are more durable than non-stick pans because they don't have coatings that can chip or flake over time. This makes them a worthwhile investment, as they will withstand the demands of your kitchen for years to come.

Making Pan Sauces

When you sear meat in a stainless steel pan, all the delicious juices and fond (the brown bits stuck to the pan) can be used to create rich and flavourful pan sauces. Deglazing the pan with wine, stock, or another liquid releases those tasty bits, forming the base for a sauce that perfectly complements your steak.

Oven Safety

Many stainless steel pans are oven-safe, which means you can start your steak on the stovetop to get a good sear and then finish it in the oven without having to transfer it to a different dish. This not only makes cooking more convenient but also helps ensure your steak is cooked to perfection.

Health Considerations

Non-stick pans have come under scrutiny due to the potential health risks associated with the chemicals used in their coatings. While these risks have been mitigated in recent years, some people still prefer the peace of mind that comes with using stainless steel pans, which don't have these coatings.

In conclusion, while non-stick pans have their place in the kitchen, particularly for cooking delicate foods like eggs or pancakes, stainless steel pans are the superior choice for searing meat. They provide even heating, durability, and the ability to create those mouth-watering flavours that come from a well-seared steak.

Non-stick pans are better for cooking eggs and pancakes

Non-stick pans are ideal for cooking eggs and pancakes due to their non-stick coating, which repels water and oil. This makes it easier to cook delicate or sticky foods without them adhering to the pan, and also means less oil or butter is needed, making non-stick pans ideal for low-fat cooking.

Non-stick pans are also easier to clean, as food doesn't stick to the surface. In some cases, all that's needed to clean a non-stick pan is a wipe with a paper towel.

However, non-stick pans do have some limitations. They cannot achieve the same golden sear on meat as stainless steel pans, and they are not suitable for prolonged high-heat cooking, so they are not ideal for oven roasting or searing. The non-stick coating is also delicate and can be damaged by metal utensils or dishwashers.

Stainless steel pans, on the other hand, are more durable and resistant to warping, denting, and scratching. They are also oven-safe and grill-safe, making them more versatile. However, they require more oil or butter to prevent food from sticking and can be more difficult to clean if food does stick.

Overall, while both types of pans have their advantages and disadvantages, non-stick pans are better suited for cooking eggs and pancakes due to their non-stick properties, ease of cleaning, and suitability for low-fat cooking.

Stainless steel is more versatile and can be used for boiling, sautéing, and baking

Stainless steel is a highly versatile material that can be used for boiling, sautéing, and baking. It is suitable for a wide range of cooking tasks, from searing meat to creating one-dish pasta recipes. Stainless steel pans are also excellent for making pan sauces, as the non-reactive nature of the material means that acidic ingredients can be used without introducing off-flavours or stripping any seasoning.

One of the key advantages of stainless steel is its durability. Stainless steel pans are more durable than non-stick pans and can last a lifetime if properly cared for. They are also lightweight, making them easier to handle than cast-iron pans. Additionally, many brands of stainless steel pans are magnetic, making them suitable for induction cooktops.

In terms of performance, stainless steel pans excel at producing the beautiful and delicious browning known as the Maillard reaction. They can also be preheated to high temperatures, making them ideal for searing and sautéing. For example, when cooking meat, a properly preheated stainless steel pan will allow you to seal the meat beautifully and easily lift it from the pan.

Stainless steel pans are also oven-safe, with most high-quality stainless steel rated for temperatures up to 500°F. This makes them perfect for dishes that require finishing in the oven, such as thick steaks or pork chops.

Overall, stainless steel is an excellent choice for boiling, sautéing, and baking due to its versatility, durability, and performance. It is a favourite among professional chefs and home cooks alike, and its lightweight and durable construction makes it a workhorse in any kitchen.

Frequently asked questions