Cheese, Meat, And More: Fondue Vs Raclette

Fondue and raclette are both Swiss dishes that involve melting cheese. But what's the difference between the two? Cheese fondue is made by melting cheese (or several different cheeses) in a pot with white wine and is eaten with bread. Raclette, on the other hand, involves melting a block of cheese, usually by grilling it, and then scraping off the melted part to be eaten with potatoes, cold meats, gherkins, and pickled onions. While fondue is more casual and low-key, raclette offers more freedom to choose your ingredients and is usually a more communal dining experience.

Fondue is a noun and a verb

Fondue is both a noun and a verb. As a noun, it refers to a dish of melted cheese served in a heated pot, typically made by combining different cheeses, melting them in a pot with white wine, and eating the mixture with bread. The word "fondue" comes from the French word "fondre", which means "to melt". Fondue is often associated with communal dining, where people dip pieces of bread into a shared pot of melted cheese. It is a social and interactive way of enjoying food with friends and family.

As a verb, "to fondue" means to dip food into a fondue pot. The act of fondue involves skewering a piece of food, such as bread or fruit, and submerging it into the melted cheese. This verb form adds to the fun and interactivity of the dining experience, encouraging participation and a sense of involvement among guests.

The popularity of fondue as a noun and a verb can be seen in its cultural impact. In the 1970s, "Let's fondue" was a common phrase, reflecting the social nature of the activity. Fondue parties and gatherings create a casual and enjoyable atmosphere, bringing people together to share a delicious and interactive meal. The verb "to fondue" also implies action and engagement, adding to the excitement of the dining experience.

Fondue, as a noun, has evolved and expanded beyond its traditional cheese and bread combination. Modern variations include adding ingredients such as herbs, paprika, cayenne, nutmeg, or mustard to the cheese mixture. Additionally, the range of dippers has expanded to include apples, pears, roasted broccoli, cauliflower, grilled sausage, and soft pretzel bites, among others. This versatility allows for customization and creativity, making fondue an even more dynamic and inclusive dining option.

In conclusion, "fondue" as a noun represents a delicious and social dining experience, while "to fondue" as a verb captures the active and engaging nature of the activity. Together, they showcase the interactive and enjoyable aspects of this communal meal, making it a beloved and enduring culinary tradition.

Raclette remained relatively unknown in the US until the 21st century

While fondue became a staple in the United States during the 20th century, raclette, another Swiss-born dish, remained relatively unknown in the country until the 21st century. Both dishes are made for sharing and centre on melted cheese, but there are some key differences that may explain why fondue gained more popularity.

Firstly, fondue is easier to prepare. It only requires a pot with a heat source, such as a small flame, to keep the cheese warm and melted. In contrast, raclette calls for more equipment and attention. It traditionally involves melting a block of cheese over an open flame and then scraping the melted portion over a plate of side dishes. While modern raclette machines have made the process more convenient, it still requires more preparation and specialised equipment than fondue.

Secondly, the nature of the two dishes may have contributed to fondue's earlier popularity. Fondue is a more casual meal, perfect for a low-key weeknight dinner. It can be customised with various dippers, such as bread, apples, or roasted vegetables, making it a versatile option. On the other hand, raclette is a more structured meal with specific steps for melting and scraping the cheese. While it offers some flexibility in terms of ingredients, it is traditionally served with boiled potatoes, cured meats, and pickles, which may not have been as appealing to the American palate when it was first introduced.

Additionally, the social aspect of fondue may have contributed to its widespread adoption. Fondue is often served in a communal pot, with guests gathering around and dipping their chosen foods into the melted cheese. This interactive and social way of dining may have been more appealing to Americans than raclette, which is typically served individually, with guests scraping their own melted cheese over their plates.

Furthermore, the portability of fondue pots may have been a factor in its popularity. Fondue pots are small and easy to transport, making them perfect for social gatherings and potluck-style dinners. In contrast, raclette machines are typically larger and more cumbersome, designed to be placed at the centre of a table.

Despite these differences, both fondue and raclette have rich histories and offer delicious, indulgent experiences. Raclette, with its traditional roots and interactive preparation, is now gaining recognition in the United States, even if it took a little longer to catch on than its fondue counterpart.

Raclette is a specific type of Swiss cheese

Raclette cheese is semi-hard and aromatic, with a flavour that ranges from mild to piquant. It is usually sliced and then melted or grilled before being served. The traditional method of preparing the cheese is to heat it by a fire and then scrape the melted cheese over a plate of side dishes. Nowadays, people use electric raclette machines or grills, which are placed in the centre of the table, to prepare the cheese.

The raclette dish is usually served with potatoes, bread, and cured meats, as well as vegetables such as mushrooms, onions, and zucchini. Small cornichon pickles are also a common addition. The beauty of this meal is that you can use other types of cheese, such as French Morbier or Italian Fontina, and you can also be flexible with the side dishes.

Raclette predates fondue, with the first references to the dish dating back to the 13th century, while the first fondue recipe appeared in 1699. Raclette is also considered more complicated to prepare than fondue, as it requires in-the-moment attention.

Fondue is a more casual meal

The fondue pot is heated by a candle placed underneath or sometimes electrically. The inside of the pot is often rubbed with a clove of garlic, and a pinch of nutmeg is added to the mixture, along with a glass of crisp, dry wine. The leftover melted cheese at the bottom of the pot is considered by some to be the best part of the fondue. It is called the religieuse and is formed by turning up the heat just enough to create a dark crust.

Fondue is also more customisable than raclette. While the latter is usually eaten with a specific Swiss-made cheese of the same name, fondue can be made with a variety of cheeses, such as Gruyère, Emmental, Vacherin, Raclette, or Cheddar.

Fondue is also more portable than raclette. The fondue pot can be easily carried, and no power cords are required – just a little flame to keep the cheese warm and melty.

In summary, fondue is a more casual, low-maintenance meal than raclette, offering more flexibility in terms of preparation, serving, and customisation.

Raclette is more complicated to make

While fondue and raclette are both Swiss dishes involving melted cheese, the preparation methods differ significantly. Raclette is more complicated to make than fondue for several reasons. Firstly, the process of melting the cheese is more intricate. For fondue, cheese is simply melted in a pot with wine, whereas for raclette, the cheese must be carefully heated and then scraped off in melted layers. This scraping process is where the name of the dish comes from, as "racler" is French for "to scrape".

The traditional method for melting raclette cheese involves holding a wheel of cheese up to a fire until it is melted, and then scraping off the melted layer. Nowadays, people use electric raclette machines or grills, which are placed in the centre of the table. These grills consist of two plates with heating conductors, between which you place mini-pans containing slices of raclette cheese. Once the cheese has melted, it is then scraped onto a plate. This process requires more time and attention than fondue, which can be left to melt in a pot.

Another reason why raclette is more complicated is that it involves more ingredients. While fondue is usually just cheese, wine, and bread, raclette is often served with boiled potatoes, meats, and various vegetables. The traditional way to serve raclette is with boiled potatoes, bread, and cured meats. However, modern takes on the dish include different types of vegetables, such as roasted pumpkin, roasted broccoli, or cauliflower.

Preparing a raclette dinner requires less advance preparation than fondue, as there is no cooking before the guests arrive other than boiling some potatoes. However, the process of melting and scraping the cheese, as well as cooking the meat and vegetables, is more complicated and time-consuming than simply melting cheese in a pot for fondue.

Frequently asked questions