Cast Iron Pan Care: Why Towels Turn Black

If your cast-iron pan leaves black marks on your towel when you wipe it down, it's likely due to carbon buildup, burnt food, or the breakdown of the seasoning. This is a common issue with cast-iron pans, and while it's not harmful, it can be unappealing. To fix this, you can try cleaning your pan with mild dish soap and hot water, using a scrubby sponge, or giving it a salt scrub. You can also try re-seasoning your pan by applying a light coat of oil and heating it in the oven.

The black residue is likely carbon buildup from burnt food

If you're noticing black residue on your towel after wiping down your cast-iron pan, it's likely due to carbon buildup from burnt food or overheating of fats and oils. This is a common issue with cast-iron cookware, and while the residue is not harmful, it can be unappealing.

To prevent and remove carbon buildup, it's important to properly clean your cast-iron pan without removing the seasoning. Here are some methods you can try:

• Use a mild dish soap and a soft sponge or scrubber to clean your pan. Modern dish soaps are gentle enough and won't harm the seasoning.
• Give your pan a salt scrub. Pour a tablespoon or two of salt into the pan and use a washcloth to scrub the surface. The salt will discolour as it absorbs the carbon residue. Remove all the salt and apply a light coat of oil.
• Soak your pan in water for about an hour, then scrub it with a small amount of soap using a stiff brush. Dry it with a towel and place it on high heat on the stove to evaporate any remaining moisture. Let the pan cool, then apply a light coat of oil.
• After cooking, put a heap of salt in the middle of the pan and spread it around with a paper towel, lightly scrubbing the surface. The salt will absorb the residue and disinfect the pan, and its abrasive properties will help with cleaning. Wipe off the now-brown salt and rub in a coat of oil.

Remember, it's normal for your cast-iron pan to develop some carbon buildup and discolouration. With proper cleaning and maintenance, you can minimise the residue and keep your pan in good condition.

The black residue is not harmful, but it is unapealing

The black residue on a cast-iron pan is likely caused by carbon buildup from burnt food or overheating fats and oils. While it may be unsightly, it is not harmful and is a common occurrence, especially with new skillets. To remove the residue, you can use one of two methods: salt or a stiff brush.

The salt method involves pouring a quarter cup of salt into the pan and using a flat-edged utensil to push the salt around, discolouring it. Afterwards, remove all the salt grains to avoid corrosion and apply a light coat of oil.

For the stiff brush method, let the pan soak in water for an hour. Then, scrub it with a small amount of soap if needed. Dry the pan with a towel, place it on high heat, and let all the moisture evaporate. Finally, apply a light coat of oil.

Another way to address the black residue is to ensure you are using an oil with the proper smoke point for your food and avoid overheating. This will help prevent the formation of black specks on your food and in your pan.

While some people choose to avoid using soap on their cast-iron pans, it is not necessarily harmful. Modern dish soaps are unlikely to strip the seasoning from your pan. However, it is important to thoroughly dry the pan after washing to prevent rusting.

To remove the black residue, use an oil with a proper smoke point for your food and avoid overheating

If you're noticing black residue on your towel after wiping your cast-iron pan, it's likely due to carbon buildup, such as burnt food or oil residue. While this residue is not harmful, it can be unsightly and affect the taste of your food. To remove the black residue, it's important to use an oil with a proper smoke point for your food and avoid overheating.

The black residue is typically caused by the use of oils with low smoke points, which carbonize at high temperatures. When cooking with cast iron, it's best to use oils with high smoke points, such as vegetable oil or canola oil. These oils can withstand higher temperatures without burning and flaking, reducing the amount of residue that transfers to your food.

Additionally, proper cleaning and maintenance of your cast-iron pan can help prevent the buildup of black residue. While it's not recommended to use soap frequently as it can strip the seasoning, you can use mild dish soap and a soft sponge or scrubber to clean your pan. Alternatively, you can use salt or baking soda as an abrasive to scrub away the residue. Rinse the pan with water and dry it thoroughly before applying a light coat of oil and placing it in the oven at a high temperature to reseason.

By using the right oils, avoiding overheating, and maintaining proper cleaning practices, you can effectively remove and prevent black residue on your cast-iron pan, ensuring your cookware remains in top condition.

You can also scrub the pan with salt or a stiff brush to remove the residue

If you're noticing black residue on your towel when you wipe down your cast-iron pan, it's likely due to carbon buildup, such as burnt food. While this residue is normal and likely won't cause any health issues, you may want to give your pan a more thorough clean. Here's where scrubbing with salt or a stiff brush comes in.

Scrubbing with Salt

Salt is an effective and gentle way to remove unwanted food and residue from your cast iron without scratching the surface. Here's a step-by-step guide:

• Pour 2-3 tablespoons of coarse kosher salt into your cast iron skillet. If you have a smaller pan, one tablespoon is enough.
• Using a clean kitchen rag or a folded paper towel, gently scour the surface of the pan with the salt.
• Once the unwanted food and residues are removed, discard the salt and rinse your pan with warm water.
• Dry your pan with a rag or paper towel.
• Place the pan on the stovetop and heat it over medium-low heat for about 5 minutes or until you see the first wisp of smoke.
• Let the pan cool until it's safe to touch, then wipe it down with a thin layer of seasoning oil (about 1/4 teaspoon). The pan should still have a matte appearance even when oiled.

Scrubbing with a Stiff Brush

When choosing a brush for your cast iron, opt for one with nylon or other synthetic bristles that are effective yet gentle and won't ruin the seasoning. Avoid metal scouring pads and steel wool unless you're restoring a rusted pan. Here's how to scrub your cast iron with a stiff brush:

• If needed, simmer a small amount of water in the pan for 3-5 minutes to loosen any stuck-on food.
• Use a stiff nylon brush or a pan scraper to scrub away any residue.
• Rinse the pan under warm water. Be sure to thoroughly dry your pan afterward to prevent rust.
• Re-season the pan by rubbing a light layer of cooking oil onto the surface. Use a paper towel to wipe the surface until no oil residue remains.

Remember, proper care for your cast iron will ensure it lasts a lifetime. While it may seem delicate, a good scrub now and then is beneficial and won't damage the pan's seasoning.

The black residue could also be due to overheating fats and oils, which have a low smoke point

The black residue on your towel after wiping your cast iron pan could be due to several reasons. One possibility is that the black residue is carbon buildup or burnt food in your pan. This is a common occurrence, especially with new skillets, and can be removed by washing the pan with mild dish soap and hot water. Another possibility is that the black residue is due to overheating fats and oils, which have a low smoke point. This can cause the oil to burn and leave a black residue on the pan, which is then transferred to the towel when wiped.

To prevent the black residue from occurring due to overheating fats and oils, it is important to maintain the proper temperature when cooking with your cast iron pan. Oils with a low smoke point, such as olive oil, vegetable oil, or flaxseed oil, should not be heated above their smoke point, as this will cause them to break down and release smoke. The smoke point of an oil is the temperature at which it begins to burn and produce smoke. For example, the smoke point of olive oil is typically around 375°F to 405°F, while the smoke point of flaxseed oil is around 445°F.

If you are using an oil with a low smoke point, it is important to heat your pan slowly and cook at a lower temperature to avoid overheating the oil. Additionally, you can try using an oil with a higher smoke point, such as avocado oil, peanut oil, or canola oil, which have smoke points above 400°F. By maintaining the proper temperature and using the appropriate oil, you can help prevent the black residue from forming on your pan and towel.

It is worth noting that uneven colouring is normal for cast iron pans, and it can take some time for the seasoning to even out. The colouring can range from red to orange to black, and it may take multiple uses before the pan develops an even black seasoning. However, if you notice a washed-out ring in the centre of your pan, it could be an indication that your pan is being subjected to too much heat.

In conclusion, the black residue on your towel could be due to overheating fats and oils with low smoke points. To prevent this, maintain proper temperatures when cooking, use oils with higher smoke points, and be mindful of the signs of overheating, such as uneven colouring or a washed-out ring. By taking these precautions, you can help keep your cast iron pan in optimal condition and avoid the formation of black residue.

Frequently asked questions