Rivets On Carbon Steel Pans: Why Care?

Carbon steel pans are a popular choice for professional chefs and home cooks alike. One of the key considerations when purchasing a carbon steel pan is the type of handle attachment, which can be either riveted or welded. While both options have their pros and cons, the choice between rivets and welds ultimately comes down to personal preference and budget. Rivets are small pieces of metal that hold two harder pieces of metal together, while welds are created by melting the pieces of metal together. Riveted handles are generally more durable and may be harder to keep hygienic due to the small spaces between the rivets and the pan where food particles and bacteria can collect. Welded handles, on the other hand, provide a smooth surface with no gaps, making them easier to clean and more hygienic. However, the welding process can be more expensive, and sudden handle failure is a potential risk with welded handles. Ultimately, both options are viable, and the decision should be based on individual needs and preferences.

Hygiene: Food and bacteria can collect in the cracks around rivets

I'm sorry, but I don't have any information to create an answer. Please let me know if there is anything else I can help with.

Ease of cleaning: Rivets can be harder to clean, especially in frying pans and saute pans

When it comes to cleaning carbon steel pans, the presence of rivets can make the task a little more challenging, especially for frying pans and saute pans. Here's why:

Higher Temperatures and Grime Build-Up

Rivets are small pieces of metal that attach the handle to the pan. In frying pans and saute pans, the higher temperatures can cause grime to burn onto or near the rivet heads. This build-up of grime can be difficult to remove, especially in the tight spaces around the rivets. An ordinary kitchen sponge may not be able to reach these areas effectively.

Disruption of Non-Stick Coatings

Non-stick coatings on pans can be interrupted by rivets, creating bumpy surfaces. Cheap pans often do not coat the rivets with a non-stick material, resulting in sticky spots. If you try to scrub these areas with a regular sponge, you may eventually damage the non-stick coating near the rivets.

Hygiene Concerns

The gaps and cracks around rivets can collect food and bacteria, making it more challenging to maintain proper hygiene. This issue is less prominent with welded handles, which have a smoother transition from the handle to the pan's sidewall.

Cleaning Tips

To address the cleaning challenges posed by rivets, you can use specialised tools such as a toothbrush or a Barkeepers Friend. Additionally, you may need to use a non-scratch sponge for non-stick pans to avoid damaging the coating. For stubborn grime, you can apply a paste of Carbon Off or a similar product, cover it with a moist paper towel, and let it sit for about 30 minutes before scrubbing.

While rivets can make cleaning a bit more tedious, some users find that the benefits of riveted handles, such as durability and ease of handle attachment, outweigh the cleaning concerns. Ultimately, the decision between riveted and welded handles depends on your personal preferences and budget.

Non-stick coatings: Rivets can interrupt the smoothness of the pan's surface

When it comes to non-stick coatings, rivets can be a hindrance as they interrupt the smoothness of the pan's surface. This can cause issues during cooking and cleaning.

Rivets are small pieces of metal that are crushed to hold two harder pieces of metal together. In the context of cookware, rivets are often used to attach handles to the pan's body. While rivets can be made from various materials, they are typically made of aluminium or steel.

When it comes to non-stick coatings, rivets can pose a problem as they create bumps or interruptions on the pan's surface. This can be especially problematic if the rivets are not coated with a non-stick material. As a result, food may stick to the rivets, making it difficult to clean the pan. Over time, the non-stick coating near the rivets may also get damaged due to the extra effort required to clean the area.

Some manufacturers address this issue by creating internally flush rivets or using welded handles instead of rivets. Welded handles provide a smooth surface without any bumps, making them more suitable for non-stick coatings. However, welded handles can also have their own set of advantages and disadvantages.

While rivets may interrupt the smoothness of non-stick coatings, it is important to note that they are generally durable and can withstand regular use in residential kitchens. Additionally, the attachment method may be less of a concern for those who prioritise comfort and convenience when choosing a pan handle.

Durability: Rivets can loosen over time, but you will have warning before they break

Carbon steel pans are a popular choice for professional chefs and home cooks alike. They are highly versatile and can be used for searing, frying, sautéing, broiling, and even cooking on an open flame. One of the key considerations when purchasing a carbon steel pan is the type of handle attachment. Riveted handles are a common choice, but how do they impact the durability of the pan?

Rivets can indeed loosen over time, but the good news is that you will typically have a warning before they break completely. This is in contrast to welded handles, which can suddenly fail without much notice. With rivets, you are likely to notice the loosening over a period, giving you time to take corrective action. This could involve having the rivets re-fastened or replaced, ensuring your pan remains functional for the long haul.

However, it is important to note that any decent stainless cookware will have well-made rivets that are unlikely to fail in a residential kitchen setting. Rivets are designed to withstand a significant amount of stress and abuse before loosening. Additionally, the quality of the rivets and the metal they are made of will play a role in their durability. Stronger rivets made from materials like stainless steel will hold up better over time compared to those made from weaker metals like aluminum.

While rivets may not be indestructible, they offer the advantage of being easier to repair or replace compared to welded handles. If a welded handle fails, it often requires more extensive repairs or even replacement of the entire pan. With rivets, you can simply hire someone to re-rivet the cookware, preserving your investment in high-quality carbon steel.

In conclusion, while rivets in carbon steel pans can loosen over time, this is typically a gradual process that provides ample warning. The durability of rivets depends on their quality and the material they are made of, but they are generally designed to withstand regular kitchen use. Additionally, the option to repair or replace loosened rivets extends the lifespan of your carbon steel pan, making it a reliable choice for your culinary adventures.

Welding: It's hard to weld handles onto aluminium and copper cookware

When it comes to cookware, the type of material used is of utmost importance. Different materials have different advantages and disadvantages, and some are better suited for specific tasks than others.

While cast iron has been a popular kitchen staple for years, professional chefs are now turning to carbon steel. Carbon steel is an alloy made from steel and carbon, just like cast iron, but in slightly different proportions. The result is a lighter, less brittle, and smoother metal that performs almost exactly like cast iron. Compared to stainless steel or aluminum, carbon steel can withstand higher temperatures and retains heat better.

One of the key considerations when choosing cookware is the type of handle and how it is attached. Rivets and welds are the most popular choices, but screwed-on handles and body-extension handles are also common. Rivets are small pieces of metal that are crushed between two harder pieces of metal to hold them together, while welds are created by melting two pieces of metal together, sometimes with a filler material.

Welded handles offer some advantages over riveted handles. They are more hygienic because there are no cracks for food and bacteria to collect in, and they are easier to wash since there are no rivet heads for grime to burn onto. Additionally, welded handles do not disrupt the smoothness of nonstick coatings, as rivets can.

However, there are also some disadvantages to welded handles. Handle failure can be sudden and severe, with no warning before the weld breaks. This can result in hot liquids spilling out. Another disadvantage is that it is challenging to weld handles onto aluminum and copper cookware. These types of cookware usually have lower softening and melting points than stainless steel, so they are often riveted instead.

In conclusion, while both rivets and welds are suitable options for attaching handles to cookware, welded handles offer some advantages in terms of hygiene and ease of cleaning. However, they may not be suitable for all types of cookware, especially aluminum and copper, due to the lower softening and melting points of these materials. Ultimately, the decision between rivets and welds may come down to personal preference and the specific needs of the chef.

Frequently asked questions