The Cast Iron Conundrum: Why Soap Is A No-Go

It is a common misconception that soap should not be used to clean cast iron pans. This myth is driven by the belief that since oil is used to season the pan and create a non-stick surface, soap would wash away the cure. However, this is not the case as the oil combines with the porous surface of the pan when heated, creating a surface harder and smoother than the pan itself. In fact, the best way to remove seasoning is to bring the pan to high heat in an oven or grill, not with soap and water.

While it is not necessary to use soap, it is perfectly safe to do so in moderation. Large amounts of soap can strip the seasoning off a cast iron pan, but it can be easily reseasoned if needed. Simply dry the pan with a lint-free cloth or paper towel, rub a light layer of cooking oil or seasoning spray onto the surface, and wipe away any excess oil residue.

Soaps no longer contain lye, which was the ingredient that stripped seasoning from cast iron pans

It is a common misconception that soap should not be used to clean cast iron pans. This idea stems from the fact that older dish soaps were made with lye, a caustic substance that can strip the seasoning and damage cast iron pans. However, this is no longer the case with modern soaps.

Lye, also known as sodium hydroxide, is a crucial ingredient in the chemical reaction called saponification that creates soap. This process combines lye with oil and results in the formation of soap and glycerin. If the saponification process is carried out correctly, there should be no lye left in the finished soap product.

While all real soaps use lye in their creation process, modern methods and measuring scales ensure that all the lye is consumed, and none remains in the final product. This means that today's soaps no longer contain lye, which was the ingredient that stripped the seasoning from cast iron pans.

It is important to note that while modern soaps are safe to use on cast iron, some powerful cleaning products, such as aerosol oven cleaners, may still contain lye or sodium hydroxide. These products can rapidly destroy the seasoning on cast iron pans and should be avoided.

Instead, mild dish soaps are recommended for cleaning cast iron skillets. While these soaps are safe to use, it is still important to properly care for your cast iron pan after washing. This includes drying the pan thoroughly and re-seasoning it with a light layer of cooking oil to maintain its non-stick properties.

Modern soaps are too mild to remove the polymerized oil that forms the non-stick surface of a cast iron pan

The non-stick surface of a cast iron pan is created by a process called polymerization. This involves heating oil or fat in the pan at a high temperature, causing it to change from a wet liquid into a slick, hardened surface. This polymerized oil combines with the porous surface of the pan, creating a harder, smoother surface.

Modern soaps are too mild to remove this polymerized oil. While older soaps were made with lye and vinegar, which could strip away oil and damage cast iron pans, today's soaps are not powerful enough to remove the seasoning. They will, however, remove excess oil left on the surface of the pan after cooking. This excess oil can be wiped away with a paper towel. Therefore, it is important to distinguish between the polymerized oil that forms the non-stick surface and the excess oil that can be safely removed with soap.

To maintain the seasoning of a cast iron pan, it is recommended to cook with oil or fat regularly. Each time you cook with oil or fat, you add another layer of seasoning to the pan. Over time, these layers build up, creating a stronger non-stick surface. It is also important to avoid using harsh detergents or abrasive cleaning tools, as these can damage the seasoning.

In summary, modern soaps are too mild to remove the polymerized oil that forms the non-stick surface of a cast iron pan. They can, however, remove excess oil, which is distinct from the polymerized oil that creates the non-stick surface. To maintain the seasoning, it is recommended to cook with oil or fat regularly and avoid using harsh cleaning products.

Soap can be used sparingly on a well-seasoned pan

While it is true that soaps decades ago were made with lye and vinegar, which would strip away oil and remove seasoning, today's soaps are much milder and won't affect a well-seasoned cast iron pan. In fact, even the fine folks at Lodge Cast Iron, with their over 120 years of experience making cast iron, endorse the use of soap.

However, it is important to only use mild dish soap and to stick to hand washing, as washing cast iron pans in the dishwasher will likely strip the seasoning off the pan. Additionally, be sure to always dry your cast iron skillet completely after washing it to prevent rust.

If you're still hesitant to use soap, you can simply wipe out the pan with a paper towel and heat it back up to dry it, killing off all the bacteria. Alternatively, you can use a hard-bristle brush or the scrubbing side of a sponge to loosen up food and debris, rinse the pan, and then dry it immediately.

So, while soap can be used sparingly on a well-seasoned cast iron pan, it's not necessary, and there are other effective ways to clean and maintain your pan.

Soap is unnecessary if you wipe the pan clean after cooking

It is a common misconception that soap should not be used to clean cast iron pans. This belief stems from the fact that older soaps were made with lye and vinegar, which could strip away the seasoning and damage the pan's iron. However, today's milder dish soaps are not powerful enough to remove baked-on seasoning. They will only rinse away surface oil and food debris, which can also be achieved by wiping the pan clean after cooking.

If you choose to use soap, it is important to avoid power cleansers or aerosol oven cleaners, as these can be too harsh and damage the pan's seasoning. Stick to mild dish soaps and always dry your cast iron skillet completely after washing to prevent rust.

If you prefer not to use soap, you can simply wipe your cast iron pan clean with a paper towel after each use. To ensure that all bacteria are killed, heat the pan back up to dry it. This method is supported by cast iron experts like Lodge Cast Iron, who have over 120 years of experience in the industry.

In summary, while soap is not necessary if you wipe your cast iron pan clean after cooking, it is also not detrimental to the pan's seasoning if used correctly. The most important factors in caring for your cast iron are ensuring that it is thoroughly dried after washing and maintaining a well-seasoned surface.

If you do use soap, it's important to dry the pan over heat after washing

If you do decide to use soap to clean your cast iron pans, it's important to take extra steps to ensure that your pan is ready to use the next time you cook. Firstly, never let the pan soak in water, and always dry it immediately after washing. Water can cause rust to form very quickly on cast iron.

To dry your pan, place it on a stove eye and heat it over medium-low heat until all the water has evaporated. Turn the stove eye off and pour a small amount of high-temperature oil, such as flaxseed, vegetable, or canola oil, into the pan. Use a paper towel to spread the oil across the surface of the pan, inside and out. Let the pan cool completely, then wipe away any excess oil. Your pan is now ready to be stored until its next use.

It's worth noting that cast iron pans are very durable and difficult to ruin. They can withstand high temperatures and are not as delicate as some people believe.

Frequently asked questions