Panhead Sprockets: Compatibility With Iron Head Engines

Harley Davidson's engines have earned nicknames over the years, such as panhead, knucklehead, shovelhead, and flathead. The panhead engine, introduced in 1948, is the easiest to identify due to its distinctive cake pan cylinder heads. The knucklehead engine, produced from 1936 to 1947, earned its nickname from the two large protruding bolts on the head, resembling two knuckles on a fist. The flathead engine, which preceded the knucklehead, is identified by the cooling fins on the cylinder head. The shovelhead engine, produced from 1966 to 1985, is the most challenging to identify, as the heads do not resemble shovels. However, by rotating a coal shovel 90 degrees, the resemblance to the cylinder head becomes apparent.

Differences between a panhead and a knucklehead

The knucklehead and panhead are both V-twin motorcycle engines made by Harley-Davidson. Here are the key differences between the two:

Knucklehead Engine:

The Knucklehead engine was Harley-Davidson's third basic type of V-Twin engine, replacing the Flathead engine in 1936. It was produced from 1936 to 1947 and was replaced by the Panhead engine in 1948. The Knucklehead engine is characterised by the distinct shape of its rocker boxes, which resemble the knuckles on a person's fist. The engine has two large protruding bolts on the right side of each cylinder head. It was originally called an "OHV" (Over-Head Valve) by enthusiasts and in Harley's official literature, but the nickname "Knucklehead" arose from the California chopper culture of the late 1960s.

Panhead Engine:

The Panhead engine was produced by Harley-Davidson from 1948 to the mid-1960s, replacing the Knucklehead engine. The distinguishing feature of the Panhead engine is its valve covers, which resemble small cake pans. The Panhead design was intended to improve oil containment, but it was not successful, and Panhead engines still leak oil from the top end. The Panhead engine was introduced just in time for the postwar motorcycle boom and was known for its power.

Visual Differences:

In addition to the distinct shapes of the rocker boxes and valve covers, there are other visual differences between the Knucklehead and Panhead engines. The Knucklehead engine has two large, protruding bolts on the right side of each cylinder head, while the Panhead engine's cake pan-shaped valve covers appear round on one side and square on the other.

Performance Differences:

The Knucklehead engine was Harley-Davidson's top-of-the-line model when it was introduced in 1936, offering improved performance over the Flathead engine. The Panhead engine, introduced after World War II, was known for its power and played a significant role in the postwar motorcycle boom. However, specific performance differences between the two engines are not readily available.

How to identify a panhead engine

The Panhead is a Harley-Davidson motorcycle engine, produced between 1948 and 1965. The engine is a two-cylinder, two-valve-per-cylinder, pushrod V-twin, made in both 61 c.i. (EL) and 74 c.i. (FL, FLH) displacements. The distinctive shape of the rocker covers, which resemble small cake pans or cooking pans, led to the engine's name.

• The production year of the bike is between 1948 and 1965.
• The engine has a two-cylinder, two-valve-per-cylinder, pushrod V-twin configuration.
• The displacement is either 61 c.i. (EL) or 74 c.i. (FL, FLH).
• The rocker covers resemble small cake pans or cooking pans.
• The engine has oil containment issues and tends to leak oil from the top end.
• The engine replaced the Knucklehead engine in 1948 and was manufactured until 1965 when it was replaced by the Shovelhead engine.

Additionally, you can refer to specific parts of the bike to identify the engine type. For example, the frame, engine, and transmission of a Panhead engine have specific casting numbers, date codes, and serial numbers that can help identify the model year.

How to identify an ironhead engine

The ironhead was a Harley-Davidson motorcycle engine produced from 1957 until 1985. It was a two-cylinder, two-valves-per-cylinder, pushrod V-twin engine. The name "ironhead" was derived from the composition of the cylinder heads, which were made of iron instead of aluminium.

Serial Numbers and Production Years:

• Early ironhead engines (1957-1969) had serial numbers stamped on the left case, below the centre of the cylinders. The first two numbers indicated the production year, for example, "58" for a 1958 model.
• From 1970 onwards, the serial numbers were stamped on the right case by the pushrod tubes. The last number and a letter indicated the production year, for example, "H4" for a 1974 model.
• Some engines had two sets of numbers due to restamping, indicating a replacement of the original cases.

Visual Inspection:

• Magneto or Circuit Breaker: If the engine has a magneto or circuit breaker sticking up on top of the right-side timing cover, it is likely a 1969 or older model.
• Primary Cover: Check the shape and material of the primary cover. Cast aluminium indicates an XLH model, while stamped tin indicates an XLCH model.
• Headlight, Gas Tank, Wheels: The XLH model had electric start and an 18-inch wheel at both ends, while the XLCH model had kick start and different wheel sizes (4.00-18 rear and 3.25-19 front).
• Oil Tank: The XLH model had a side-mount oil tank, while the XLCH model had a centre-mount oil tank.
• Battery: The XLH model had a large centre-mount battery, while the XLCH model had no battery or a small left-side mount battery.

Other Characteristics:

• The ironhead engine was replaced by the Evolution engine in 1986.
• The name "ironhead" was applied to the Harley-Davidson Sportster motorcycles that used this engine.

By following these identification methods, you can determine whether you have an ironhead engine and gain insights into its production year and specific model variations.

Differences between a panhead and a shovelhead

While riders may refer to their Harley-Davidson motorcycles as Panheads or Shovelheads, these are not names of models but of the engines. The distinguishing feature of each of these engines is the shape of their heads, which serve as valve covers. Each head is uniquely shaped and the inspiration behind each engine name. Here are the differences between a Panhead and a Shovelhead engine:

Production Years

The Panhead engine was produced from 1948 to the mid-1960s, when it was replaced by the Shovelhead. The Shovelhead engine was produced from the mid-1960s to the early 1980s.

Design

The Shovelhead engine was created to generate more power for heavier Harley-Davidson bikes with electric start and rear suspension. The shallow chambers of the Shovelheads aided in cooling and performed better at higher compression ratios. However, the engine underwent a series of updates. The Panhead engine, on the other hand, was designed to aid in oil containment, but it was not successful, as Panheads still leak oil from the top end.

Identification

The Shovelhead engine is the most difficult to identify because its shape does not resemble that of a traditional shovel. Instead, it looks more like an upside-down coal shovel. The Panhead engine, on the other hand, is the easiest to identify, as its valve covers resemble small cake pans.

Differences between a panhead and a flathead

The flathead engine was Harley Davidson's first V-twin engine, which they began using in 1907. It is identified by the cooling fins on the cylinder head.

The flathead was followed by the Knucklehead engine in 1936, which was a major innovation for Harley. The Knucklehead got its name from the two large protruding bolts on the head, which looked like two knuckles on a fist.

Harley introduced the Panhead engine in 1948, after World War II. It is the easiest to identify because the cylinder heads look like cake pans.

The flathead and panhead engines are different in appearance, with the flathead usually having cooling fins on the heads, and the panhead looking like it has been covered by cake pans. The flathead was also an earlier design, with the Knucklehead coming out in between the flathead and the panhead.

Frequently asked questions