Ceramic Non-Stick Pans: Are They Safe Or Toxic?

Non-stick pans have long been popular for their convenience, but they have also gained a bad reputation for health and safety reasons. Traditional non-stick coatings contain compounds like PFOA or PTFE, which are highly toxic and have been linked to cancer, hormone disruption, organ failure, reproductive damage, and other health issues. Ceramic-coated cookware has emerged as a safer alternative to traditional non-stick pans, but is it truly non-toxic?

Ceramic coating can be damaged easily, potentially exposing you to harmful metals

The soft ceramic coating starts chipping away after several months of everyday use. When that happens, lead and cadmium that are sometimes found in the coating will end up in your food and later in your body. Lead poisoning is one of the most dangerous types of metal poisoning and can result in abdominal pain, headaches, infertility, and other health complications (and in severe cases, coma and death). Even when the coating is lead-free, chipped cookware can still present dangers—it's usually neurotoxic aluminium that's under the ceramic coating.

Aluminium exposure is proven to be carcinogenic and neurodegenerative. Furthermore, increasing aluminium levels in the body of a pregnant woman can trigger problems with the fetus's development. Because of that, regulations have been made to prevent aluminium exposure in the population. The European Food Safety Authority (EFSA) reported a limit of 1mg/kg of body weight/week of aluminium as a recommended limitation.

The amount of aluminium obtained from cooking vessels and food storage items can significantly increase the total uptake of aluminium. In their report, the EFSA stated: "Under normal and typical conditions, the contribution of migration from food contact materials would represent only a small fraction of the total dietary exposure. However, the Panel noted that in the presence of acids and salts, the use of aluminium-based pans, bowls, and foils for foods such as apple puree, rhubarb, tomato puree, or salted herring could result in increased aluminium concentrations in such foods."

Other studies have shown that acidic food like tomato sauce, apple puree, and rhubarb can contribute to 50-100 mg/kg-food of aluminium. That is an amount worth considering if we know that the TWI (total weekly intake) is set at 75mg for the average person who weighs around 75kg.

Aluminium-based alloys are used for the aluminium non-stick cookware base. These alloys can contain different elements, including heavy metals. The maximally allowed exposure limits for heavy metals are several thousand times less than in the case of aluminium. For instance, lead exposure should be limited to 0.5 micrograms a day. To put that into perspective, that is an amount that is two million times smaller than 1 gram.

So, when it comes to such small quantities, even contact between the food and the metal base through scratches can be significant. Food-grade aluminium needs to be tested for heavy metals, and their limits are strictly controlled. However, the metal body of cooking vessels doesn't necessarily need to be produced from food-grade metal, so they may contain amounts of heavy metals that can negatively affect health.

Some aluminium alloys contain lead because it improves alloy machinability. According to US law, aluminium can contain up to 0.5 per cent of lead. In this document, you can find international alloy designations and chemical composition limits for aluminium alloys. So, it could be expected that this heavy metal is present in some alloys used in cookware manufacturing (especially in developing countries).

One recent study that tested heavy metal content in 43 metal cookware products from more than ten countries found a huge amount of these elements in the majority of the samples.

Therefore, if your ceramic-coated cookware is damaged, it is better to recycle it. By "damaged", I mean cookware with scratches that reveal the metal body. Scratches that don't touch the metal don't need to be considered a problem.

Ceramic coating is made from multiple layers of silica, which is considered safe but not proven

Silica, also known as silicon dioxide (SiO2), is a natural compound found in materials such as quartz and sand. It is the main component in ceramic coatings, providing the hard, glossy, and hydrophobic characteristics that make ceramic coatings popular. Silica forms a strong covalent bond with the surface it is applied to, creating a protective layer that is resistant to scratches, stains, and other damage.

However, the safety of ceramic coatings in cookware has been debated. While silica itself is considered safe, other chemicals used in the ceramic coating process may raise concerns. For example, some ceramic coatings may contain lead or cadmium, which can leach into food if the coating chips. Additionally, the application process and proper curing of the coating are crucial to ensure its safety. Improper application or curing may result in the release of toxic fumes or the deterioration of the coating over time.

Furthermore, the durability of ceramic coatings is a factor in their safety. Ceramic coatings are known to chip after several months of everyday use, exposing the underlying materials, which may include neurotoxic aluminum or other harmful substances. Therefore, it is essential to invest in high-quality ceramic cookware and follow proper care instructions to maintain the integrity of the coating.

Overall, while silica itself is considered safe, the safety of ceramic coatings as a whole is more complex and depends on various factors. It is important for consumers to research the specific brand and product, ensure proper usage and care, and be aware of any potential risks associated with ceramic-coated cookware.

Teflon coating, used in traditional non-stick pans, can be toxic

Teflon is a brand-name non-stick coating made of polytetrafluoroethylene (PTFE). It was first manufactured in the 1930s and is used to create a non-stick, non-reactive, waterproof, and non-corrosive surface. While its primary use is in cookware, Teflon is also used as a coating for fabrics and wires due to its stability.

The controversy surrounding Teflon stems from its previous use of perfluorooctanoic acid (PFOA), a chemical linked to various health issues. PFOA was used in the production of Teflon until 2013, and while it was assumed to burn off during the manufacturing process, traces of it were found in some Teflon-coated cookware. PFOA has been associated with an increased risk of cancers, including kidney, prostate, bladder, ovarian, and thyroid cancer. It has also been linked to infertility, low birth weight, and other health complications.

In response to these concerns, the US Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) launched the PFOA Stewardship Program in 2006, which aimed to eliminate the use of PFOA by 2015. As a result, all Teflon products, including non-stick cookware, have been PFOA-free since 2013.

However, while modern non-stick cookware is generally considered safe for everyday home cooking, there are still concerns about other chemicals used in the making of Teflon. Per- and polyfluoroalkyl substances (PFAS) are a group of chemicals that may pose health risks, and research is ongoing to understand their impact on the human body fully.

Additionally, at temperatures above 500°F (260°C), Teflon coatings begin to break down, releasing toxic fumes. These fumes can cause polymer fume fever, also known as Teflon flu, which includes temporary flu-like symptoms such as chills, fever, headache, and body aches.

To minimize the risk of exposure to toxic fumes, it is recommended to follow basic safety precautions when cooking with non-stick cookware:

• Avoid preheating an empty pan
• Cook on medium or low heat and avoid broiling
• Use wooden, silicone, or plastic utensils
• Gently hand wash pots and pans with a sponge and warm, soapy water
• Replace old cookware when the Teflon coating starts to visibly deteriorate

While the health effects of overheated Teflon are serious, using common-sense cooking practices can help reduce the risk of exposure to toxic fumes.

Ceramic coating is more durable than Teflon coating

While ceramic and Teflon coatings are similar in many ways, ceramic coatings offer greater durability.

Teflon coatings are made from a synthetic chemical called PFOA (perfluorooctanoic acid), which is used to make polytetrafluoroethylene (PTFE). This synthetic compound is known for its non-stick properties, but it has been linked to various health issues, including cancer, hormone disruption, organ failure, and reproductive damage. Although newer Teflon coatings no longer contain PFOA, they may still contain PTFE, which is considered a carcinogen. Additionally, high heat can cause these chemicals to break down and release toxic fumes, posing health risks.

On the other hand, ceramic coatings are generally considered safe and non-toxic. They are made from natural materials and are free of heavy metals, polymers, coatings, and dyes. While some ceramic coatings may contain harmful materials like lead or cadmium, those made in the US by reputable retailers are lead-free and safe for cooking.

In terms of durability, ceramic coatings outperform Teflon. While both types of coatings have a lifespan of around 3 to 5 years, ceramic coatings are less likely to scratch or wear down. Teflon coatings, on the other hand, are more susceptible to chipping and degradation over time. This is especially true if metal utensils are used, as they can damage the coating. Ceramic coatings, however, can withstand wooden utensils without scratching.

Furthermore, ceramic coatings are more heat-resistant than Teflon. Teflon coatings should not be heated above 500 degrees Fahrenheit, as they may begin to break down and release toxic particles and gases. Ceramic coatings, on the other hand, can withstand higher temperatures without breaking down, making them a safer option for cooking.

In summary, while both ceramic and Teflon coatings offer non-stick properties, ceramic coatings are more durable and safer. They are less likely to scratch or wear down, and they can withstand higher temperatures without releasing toxic fumes. Therefore, if you're looking for a long-lasting and safe non-stick option, ceramic coatings are the way to go.

Ceramic coating is naturally slick and free of toxic chemicals

Ceramic coating is a safer alternative to traditional non-stick coatings like Teflon. While ceramic coating is slick, it does not contain the toxic chemicals found in other non-stick coatings.

Teflon is made with a synthetic chemical called PFOA (perfluorooctanoic acid), which is used to make polytetrafluoroethylene (PTFE). These chemicals are part of a group known as Perfluorinated Substances (PFASs). When heated, these chemicals break down and release toxic fumes, which can lead to flu-like symptoms and have been linked to various health issues, including cancer, hormone disruption, organ failure, and reproductive damage.

In contrast, ceramic coating is naturally slick and free of these toxic chemicals. It provides a non-stick surface without the use of PFOA, PTFE, or other PFAS. This makes ceramic cookware a healthier option, as you can cook without worrying about ingesting toxic chemicals or inhaling their fumes.

Additionally, ceramic coating is less prone to chipping, which further reduces the risk of ingesting toxic materials. The higher-quality non-stick properties of ceramic coating mean that food is less likely to stick, reducing the need for excess scrubbing and minimizing the chance of the coating flaking into your food.

Overall, ceramic coating offers a safe and healthy cooking experience, allowing you to enjoy the benefits of a non-stick surface without exposing yourself to harmful chemicals.

Frequently asked questions