Heating Olive Oil: Pan First Or Last?

There are conflicting opinions on whether to heat a pan before adding olive oil. Some sources claim that heating the pan first is a myth, while others argue that it is necessary to prevent the oil from burning or sticking. However, the general consensus is that the pan and oil should be heated together to ensure even cooking and to avoid overheating the oil. Ultimately, the decision may depend on the type of pan and the specific cooking technique being used.

Non-stick pans should have oil added when cold

When cooking with a non-stick pan, it is best to add oil before heating the pan. Non-stick pans can emit unhealthy fumes if heated without oil, and the heat can ruin the coating on the pan. Oil heats up quickly, so it is important to watch the pan to ensure that you add the food when the oil is hot.

The surface of a pan, even a non-stick one, is covered with small cracks and ruts. When cooking with a non-stick pan, adding oil to a cold pan ensures that the oil will fill these cracks and prevent food from sticking to the pan.

Some cooks prefer to add oil to a cold non-stick pan because the appearance of the oil in the pan can indicate when the pan has reached the proper temperature for cooking. Adding oil to a cold non-stick pan can also be safer than heating the pan without oil, as it is easier to forget about a hot, empty pan and accidentally leave it on the stove for too long.

It is important to note that if you are using a different type of pan, such as stainless steel, you should add the oil to a hot pan. The high temperature of the pan will reduce the viscosity of the oil and allow it to settle into the small cracks and pores in the pan.

Stainless steel pans should have oil added when hot

When cooking with stainless steel, it is best to heat the pan before adding oil. This is because the surface of a stainless steel pan is porous at a microscopic level. When the pan is heated, the metal expands, closing these pores. If oil is added to a cold pan, it will seep into these pores, and when the pan is heated, the oil will be trapped, making the pan harder to clean and more likely to cause food to stick.

When a stainless steel pan is heated before oil is added, the oil will warm up on contact with the pan, becoming looser and more fluid. This will allow the oil to spread out and coat the pan without needing to shake the pan. This creates a smoother, tighter, sleeker surface for the oil to slide on, and prevents food from getting stuck in the pores as they close when the pan heats up.

To check if your stainless steel pan is hot enough, you can use the "water test". Flick a drop of water onto the surface of the dry pan. If it sizzles, the pan is at a medium heat. If the water rolls around on the surface of the pan, it is at a medium-high or high heat. Then, you can add your oil.

When adding oil to a hot stainless steel pan, heat the oil until it is shimmering, but not smoking. This will bring the oil up to the appropriate temperature for cooking.

Olive oil is a good choice for pan-frying and sautéing

Olive oil is a great choice for pan-frying and sautéing. It has a high smoke point, which is the temperature at which the oil starts to smoke and break down, and the flavour begins to change. The smoke point of olive oil is high enough for almost all stove-top cooking and can be safely heated beyond its smoke point.

The smoke point of olive oil is between 325 and 375°F (165 to 190°C) or over 400°F, depending on the source. A normal temperature for pan-frying (sautéing) is around 250°F, while a normal range for deep-frying is between 320 and 356°F.

Olive oil is also one of the healthiest cooking staples around. It has been named “the healthiest fat on Earth” as it can reduce the risk of heart disease.

Some people believe that olive oil shouldn't be used for frying because it has a low smoke point and its flavour could be altered at higher temperatures. However, this is a misconception. Extra virgin olive oil is the most stable oil when heated and does not change as much as other oils when exposed to high heat.

When frying or roasting food, choose an oil with a smoke point above 375°F. Foods that only need to be sautéed can be cooked with oil that has a lower smoke point.

Oil heats up almost instantly when added to a hot pan

When it comes to cooking with oil, there are two schools of thought: adding oil to a hot pan or adding oil to a cold pan and heating them together. The former is often regarded as a myth, but there are some instances where adding oil to a hot pan is beneficial.

Oil heats up almost instantly

Benefits of adding oil to a hot pan

Adding oil to a hot pan can be beneficial in certain situations. For example, if you are using an unseasoned stainless steel pan, adding oil to a hot pan can help it settle into the small cracks and pores, preventing food from sticking.

Additionally, if you are cooking with butter or garlic, it is recommended to add them to a hot pan as they can burn if the pan is too hot. By adding them to a hot pan, you can quickly add your food before the butter or garlic burns.

Benefits of heating oil with the pan

Heating the oil with the pan is generally considered the preferred method as it provides better control over the temperature. This is especially important if you are cooking below the smoke point of the oil, as adding oil to a hot pan can increase the risk of it smoking and degrading.

Furthermore, heating the oil with the pan can help prevent sticking, as the oil has more time to settle into the cracks and pores of the pan.

Factors to consider

The decision to add oil to a hot or cold pan may also depend on the type of pan you are using. For non-stick pans, it is generally recommended to add oil to a cold pan as heating an empty non-stick pan can cause the coating to break down and emit unhealthy fumes.

For cast iron or stainless steel pans, preheating the pan before adding oil is often suggested to achieve better searing or browning.

In conclusion, while oil heats up almost instantly when added to a hot pan, the decision to add oil to a hot or cold pan depends on various factors, including the type of pan, the temperature required for cooking, and personal preference.

Preheating a pan can be dangerous

Even with regular pans, preheating can be dangerous. Pans heat up faster when empty, so you're more likely to burn yourself or start a fire. It's also easier to forget about an empty pan on the stove, and if you leave it unattended, it could start a pan fire.

Another danger of preheating a pan is that it can cause the oil to degrade and release toxic chemicals. However, this mostly happens when the oil is heated above its smoke point, which is well above the temperature required for most cooking tasks.

In conclusion, whether you preheat the pan or add oil first depends on your cookware and the temperature you're cooking at. If you're using a non-stick pan or cooking above the smoke point of the oil, it's best to add the oil first. Otherwise, it's mostly a matter of preference. Just make sure the pan is hot enough when you add the food to prevent sticking.

Frequently asked questions