How To Roast A Turkey: Water Or No Water?

Whether or not to add water to the pan when roasting a turkey is a highly contested topic. Some sources claim that adding water can help keep the turkey moist and regulate the temperature, while others argue that it can lead to spotty browning, less flavorful meat and drippings, and a longer cooking time. Ultimately, the decision depends on the desired outcome. If a moist texture is the priority, adding a small amount of water to the pan can be beneficial. However, if a crispy exterior is the goal, it is better to forgo the water and explore other methods to retain moisture, such as basting, brining, or using compound butter under the skin.

Pros of adding water include moisture retention and temperature regulation

Adding water to the pan when roasting a turkey has several advantages, including moisture retention and temperature regulation.

Firstly, adding water to the roasting pan can help keep the turkey moist. As the oven heats up, steam is generated, which circulates within the oven and prevents the turkey from drying out. This technique is especially useful if you are aiming for a juicy, succulent turkey.

Secondly, water can assist in moderating the temperature during the cooking process. Since water evaporates at 212°F (100°C), it acts as a buffer, preventing the cooking environment from reaching excessively high temperatures too quickly. This, in turn, promotes more even cooking, ensuring that your turkey is cooked thoroughly and consistently.

Additionally, adding water to the pan can be beneficial if you plan to make gravy. The water mixes with the turkey's juices and drippings, creating a flavorful base for your gravy. This enhances the taste of your final sauce, making it a tasty addition to your meal.

While there are valid concerns about adding water, such as the potential for soggy skin and diluted drippings, the benefits of moisture retention and temperature regulation make it a viable option, especially if you prioritize a moist and evenly cooked turkey.

Cons include dilution of drippings, soggy skin, and longer cooking times

There are several reasons why you might want to avoid adding water to the pan when roasting a turkey.

Firstly, water can dilute the drippings from the turkey, which are used as a base for gravy. This dilution can result in a less flavorful gravy, affecting the overall taste of the dish.

Secondly, the steam generated from the water can make the turkey skin soggy, rather than crispy and golden-brown. Many people consider the skin to be one of the best parts of a roasted turkey, so a soggy skin can be a significant drawback.

Finally, water in the pan can increase the cooking time. The oven needs to heat the water in addition to cooking the turkey, which can be a problem if you're working with tight timings or have multiple dishes in the oven.

While adding water can help prevent the drippings from burning and can contribute to a moister cooking environment, it may not be the best option if you prioritize flavor, crispiness, and efficient cooking times.

Water can be replaced with vegetables to catch drippings

When roasting a turkey, it is not recommended to add water to the bottom of the roasting pan. Cooking a turkey with steam is not the preferred method for cooking your turkey. It may result in spotty browning, less flavorful meat and drippings, and a mess in your oven from spattering or popping.

Instead, it is suggested to use a flat rack roast method, where the turkey is lifted off the bottom of the pan. This allows for better heat circulation and more flavourful juices. If you don't have a rack, you can form a 'coil of foil' by crushing a long length of foil into a 'rope' and placing it on the bottom of your roasting pan. Alternatively, you can use whole raw vegetables like carrots, celery, and onions to lift the turkey off the bottom of the pan.

Using vegetables to catch the drippings has multiple benefits. It prevents the juices from burning or browning at the bottom of the pan and results in tasty vegetables that can be enjoyed alongside the turkey. Additionally, the drippings can be used to make a delicious vegetable gravy or a nutritious soup.

So, if you're looking for an alternative to adding water to your turkey pan, consider using vegetables instead. They will not only help catch the drippings but also enhance the flavour and presentation of your roasted turkey.

A flat rack or coil of foil can be used to raise the turkey above the pan

If you're cooking a turkey, you might be wondering whether to add water to the pan. While it's a common practice, it's actually not recommended by the experts. Cooking a turkey with steam is a moist heat-cooking method, but it's not the preferred way to cook a turkey.

So, what's the best way to cook a turkey? Well, a flat rack roast is considered the most foolproof method. This involves roasting the turkey on a flat rack in a roasting pan, so the turkey is lifted off the bottom of the pan. This allows for heat circulation and exposes more of the pan surface to heat. Ideally, a flat rack or a V-rack with a stable base should be used.

But what if you don't have a rack? Not to worry! You can create a makeshift rack by crushing a long length of foil into a 'rope' and forming it into a ring, which is referred to as a coil of foil. This will also lift the turkey off the bottom of the pan and allow for heat circulation. Alternatively, you can use whole raw vegetables like carrots, celery, or potatoes to elevate the turkey.

Using a flat rack or coil of foil to raise the turkey above the pan has several benefits. It helps to produce an excellent golden-brown turkey with a rich roasted flavor and tender, juicy meat. It also prevents spotty browning, ensures the meat stays on the bone, and allows the turkey to develop its flavorful juices, resulting in more concentrated drippings for gravy.

The foil tent method can be used to prevent dryness

The foil tent method is a great way to prevent your turkey from drying out during roasting. This method is all about controlling the rate of browning. By reflecting some of the radiant heat coming from the oven walls and heating elements, the foil tent slows the speed at which the turkey will brown through the Maillard reaction. This chemical reaction requires high temperatures and low moisture to occur.

The foil tent method is not the same as wrapping the turkey tightly in foil. If you were to do that, the turkey would steam, and steaming doesn't create the right conditions for the Maillard reaction, so you'd end up with a very pale bird.

When using the foil tent method, you can always remove the tent for the last few minutes of cooking if the turkey is almost done but still a little pale. This is a simple fix, but remember, when it comes to cooking, it's easier to add to than take away. Tent early in the cooking process to prevent over-browning, as this process cannot be reversed.

To create a foil tent, place a sheet of foil over the turkey, leaving 1 inch between the top of the turkey and the foil tent for heat circulation. Crimp the foil onto the long sides of the pan. You can also place a piece of foil about the size of a notebook sheet over the breast about two-thirds through the roast time to prevent over-browning.

Frequently asked questions