Water For Roasting Pans: How Much?

Whether you're preparing a roast for Thanksgiving or a regular Sunday dinner, you might be wondering if you should add water to your roasting pan. While it may be tempting to add water to ensure your meat is moist, doing so can lead to several undesirable outcomes. Firstly, water can cause spotty and uneven browning, making your roast look underdone even when it's fully cooked. Secondly, water can prevent the formation of a crispy exterior and may cause the meat to fall off the bones, taking away the joy of handheld drumsticks. Thirdly, water can dilute the flavour of your roast and the drippings, resulting in a less tasty meal and lacklustre gravy. Finally, adding water can lead to a messy oven, as the fat drips from the meat into the water, causing splatters. So, when it comes to roasting, it's best to stick with fat or oil and leave the water out of your pan.

Water creates spotty browning and deceptive appearances

One of the main reasons why you shouldn't add water to your roasting pan is that it can cause spotty, uneven browning on your food, making it look underdone and unattractive. This can be especially disappointing when presenting a roast to guests, as it may create unnecessary stress and doubt about your cooking skills.

The reason this happens is that water evaporates and steams during the cooking process, preventing the food from browning properly. This results in a deceptive appearance that suggests the food is not fully cooked, even when it is.

To achieve a nice, even browning on your roast, it's best to avoid adding water to the roasting pan. Instead, opt for using fat or oil, which will help create a crispy exterior and a moist interior—the hallmark of a perfectly roasted meal.

Additionally, the steam created by adding water can cause the meat to separate from the bones, taking away from the traditional experience of enjoying handheld drumsticks, especially when it comes to iconic dishes like Thanksgiving turkey.

In conclusion, while adding water to a roasting pan may seem like a way to increase moisture, it often leads to spotty browning and deceptive appearances. To achieve the desired browning and crispy texture, it's best to stick with using fat or oil in the roasting pan.

Meat separates from the bone

When it comes to roasting meat, there are a few guidelines to follow to ensure the best results. One common question is whether to add water to the bottom of the roasting pan. While water can increase the moistness of the meat, it can also lead to poor browning and uneven cooking. The fat is what allows the meat to brown and creates a crispy exterior and moist interior.

Now, if your goal is to have meat that falls away from the bone, then water may be your solution. However, it is recommended to use stock or wine instead to add flavour. Water doesn't add flavour and will water down the flavour of any drippings you want to use for gravy. The water will also steam your roast instead of roasting it, and can make vegetables mushy.

If you're cooking a turkey, adding water can cause it to become too moist and collapse, falling away from the bones. Most chefs avoid using water when roasting a chicken, and simply oil and season the bird.

So, if you want your meat to fall off the bone, water can help, but be aware of the potential downsides and consider using stock or wine for added flavour.

Flavours are lost in the steam

When it comes to roasting, the general consensus is that water should be avoided in the bottom of the roasting pan. This is because water will evaporate and steam during the cooking process, resulting in food that doesn't brown properly. The purpose of roasting is to achieve a nice, crispy exterior and a moist interior. This is best accomplished by using a fat or oil, which allows the meat to brown and crust.

However, there are some instances where water may be desirable. If you want your meat to be ultra-moist and fall off the bone, water (or stock/wine for added flavour) can help achieve this. Additionally, water can be useful if you're roasting a whole chicken, as it can keep the chicken moist, prevent scorching on the bottom of the pan, and add flavour to the skin.

The amount of water you use in a roasting pan will depend on the size of the pan and the amount of food you're cooking. As a general rule, you should use enough water to cover the bottom of the pan by a few millimetres. This will help to ensure that the food doesn't stick and will create some steam to keep the food moist.

Now, onto the topic of whether flavours are lost in the steam. It is true that steam can carry flavour molecules and deposit them onto food, which is why steam distillation is used to create perfumes and extract aromatic molecules. However, it's important to note that not all flavour compounds will evaporate with steam, and the effectiveness will vary depending on the specific compound. Additionally, steam can dilute the flavour of drippings left in the roasting pan, making it more difficult to create a tasty gravy.

So, while some flavour can be carried by steam, it's important to consider the type of food being cooked and the desired outcome. For example, if you're roasting meat and want a nice brown crust, using only steam may not be the best method as it can interfere with the browning process. On the other hand, if you're cooking something like sticky rice in a bamboo basket, adding water and aromatics like lemongrass, ginger, and kaffir lime leaf can impart delicious flavours to the rice. Ultimately, it's a balance and a personal preference depending on the desired outcome of your dish.

Drippings and gravy are diluted

The purpose of roasting is to achieve a nice, crispy exterior and a moist interior. This is best done by using fat or oil, which allows the meat to brown and crust during the roasting process.

However, there are instances where you may want the meat to be ultra-moist and fall away from the bone. In such cases, you can use water, stock, or wine to add moisture. It is worth noting that water does not add flavour, so if you're looking for a more flavourful roast, it is recommended to use oil or fat.

When making gravy, it is important to avoid diluting the drippings, as this will reduce the flavour. The drippings are the seasoned juices extracted from the roasted meat, containing a lot of flavour. To make gravy, you will need to thicken the drippings with a roux (a mixture of fat and flour) or cornstarch. You can also add broth or stock to complement the meat, as well as milk to add creaminess.

Water can cause a mess in the oven

In a gas oven, water that spills or boils over could fall onto the flame, potentially causing safety issues such as fires or smoke. In an electric oven, water is unlikely to cause a fire, but it can still create a mess and impact the oven's performance. For example, if water is poured into an electric oven to soak, it can damage the enamel and cause the oven's mechanisms to malfunction.

To avoid a mess in the oven, it is recommended to avoid adding water to the bottom of a roasting pan. The water will evaporate and steam during the cooking process, preventing food from browning properly. Instead, oils or fats are recommended to add moisture and flavour to roasted meats and vegetables.

Additionally, it is important to regularly clean the oven to prevent a build-up of mess and to ensure optimal performance. However, it is advised to avoid using abrasive cleaners, as these can damage the enamel and cause malfunctions.

Frequently asked questions