Tube Pan Vs Bundt Pan: What's The Difference?

Tube pans and Bundt pans are similar in many ways, but they are not always interchangeable. A tube pan is any type of round baking pan with a hollow tube in its centre. A Bundt pan is a type of tube pan, but it has fluted sides that give cakes a decorative sculpted shape. Tube pans, on the other hand, typically have straight sides. Tube pans are ideal for light and airy cakes, like angel food or chiffon cakes, while Bundt pans are better for denser cakes, like butter, coffee, and pound cakes.

Tube pans are for light and airy cakes

Tube pans are perfect for light and airy cakes. Their straight sides and uncoated finish allow the batter to cling to the sides, helping the cake rise tall and preventing it from collapsing. This is why they are often called "angel food pans" or "angel food cake pans". Angel food cakes get their loft from the air whipped into the batter, rather than from leaveners like baking powder.

The tube in the centre of the pan helps conduct heat, allowing the cake to bake evenly from the inside out and preventing the cake from collapsing in the centre or becoming overly dense. This results in a cake with a uniform texture and a taller, more dramatic rise.

Tube pans are typically made of aluminium or stainless steel, and they come in various sizes and shapes to accommodate different recipes. They are ideal for chiffon cakes, sponge cakes, pound cakes, and other light and airy desserts that require even baking and a tall, uniform rise.

When preparing a tube cake pan, it is important to grease the pan with a thin layer of butter or oil, followed by a dusting of flour to create a non-stick coating. This will help to prevent the cake from sticking to the pan.

Bundt pans are for denser cakes

A bundt pan is a type of tube pan, but not all tube pans are bundt pans. Tube pans are round baking pans with a hollow tube in the centre. The tube conducts heat, helping cakes bake faster and release more easily from the pan. Bundt pans, on the other hand, typically have fluted sides, giving cakes a decorative, sculpted shape. They are ideal for denser, buttery cakes with a moist crumb, such as butter, coffee, and pound cakes. The ideal bundt pan is non-stick, with a light-coloured interior, as darker pans tend to over-brown cakes due to better heat conduction.

The distinctive shape of bundt pans makes them a versatile choice in the kitchen. Besides cakes, bundt pans can be used to make jell-o salads, ice rings for punch bowls, jalapeño poppers, bread, and even a ring-shaped lasagna. They can also be used for non-food purposes, such as making a planter or a holiday wreath.

When it comes to baking cakes, the choice between a bundt pan and a tube pan depends on the type of cake being made. Tube pans are ideal for cakes with a light and airy crumb, such as angel food or chiffon cakes. The straight sides and uncoated finish of tube pans allow the batter to cling and expand, resulting in a lofty cake. In contrast, bundt pans are better suited for denser cakes, as the intricate crevices and fluted sides can make it challenging to release airy cakes without mess.

While bundt pans and tube pans share some similarities, it is important to consider their unique characteristics when deciding which one to use. The shape, material, and functionality of each pan can significantly impact the baking process and the final product.

Tube pans have straight sides

Tube pans are round baking pans with a hollow tube in the centre, which helps conduct heat and allows large, deep cakes to bake faster. The tube and removable sides also help to easily invert and remove the cake from the pan after baking. Tube pans are typically made with a one-piece or two-piece design, with a removable flat round bottom.

While tube pans are primarily used for angel food and sponge cakes, they can also be used for pound cakes, fruitcakes, and pull-apart bread. However, it is important to note that two-piece tube pans may leak when filled with liquidy batters or ingredients. To prevent leaking, it is recommended to line the pan with parchment paper and wrap the base with aluminium foil, as well as placing the pan on a baking sheet to catch any drips.

Bundt pans have fluted sides

A Bundt pan is a type of tube pan, but the two are not interchangeable. Tube pans usually have straight sides, while Bundt pans have fluted sides, which give cakes a decorative, sculpted shape. The fluted sides of Bundt pans are not smooth, but rather ridged or patterned with designs like fruit or still life scenes.

The fluted sides of a Bundt pan allow more of the cake to be in contact with the edges of the pan, which helps the heat to be distributed more evenly. This is particularly important for dense, buttery cakes with a moist crumb, like pound cakes, butter cakes, and coffee cakes. The fluted shape of the pan, along with the hole in the middle, allows air and heat to rise through the centre of the cake, cooking it evenly.

The ideal Bundt pan is non-stick, light-coloured, and one-piece. Dark grey or black pans tend to overbake or over-brown cakes because they conduct heat better.

Tube pans are not always interchangeable with Bundt pans

Tube pans and Bundt pans are not always interchangeable. While a Bundt pan is a type of tube pan, the same is not true in reverse.

Tube pans are round baking pans with a hollow tube in the centre. They are used for large, deep cakes, and the tube helps the cakes bake faster and be released from the pan more easily. Tube pans typically have straight, uncoated sides, and are ideal for light and airy cakes like angel food or chiffon cakes. This is because the straight, uncoated sides allow the batter to cling and rise, without the need for leaveners. Tube pans often have a removable bottom and "feet" to prevent the delicate cake from collapsing and make it easier to remove the cake from the pan.

Bundt pans, on the other hand, typically have fluted sides, giving cakes a decorative, sculpted shape. They are ideal for dense, buttery cakes with a moist crumb, like butter, coffee, and pound cakes. Bundt pans are also usually made from cast aluminium, while tube pans are not.

Recipes that specifically call for a tube pan and use whipped egg whites for a light and fluffy batter should not be baked in a Bundt pan. The cake may not rise properly, and the batter may get stuck in the intricate crevices of the pan, resulting in a messy-looking cake.

However, you can use a tube pan for recipes that call for a Bundt pan in many cases, although you should keep in mind that tube pans typically hold more batter than a Bundt pan of the same size.

Frequently asked questions