Gotham Vs Granite: Which Pan Wins?

When it comes to non-stick cookware, Gotham Steel and Granite Rock are two of the most popular brands. But how do they compare, and which one should you choose for your kitchen?

Gotham Steel cookware is made with a titanium and ceramic blend, while Granite Rock features a granite-like non-stick coating infused with minerals. Both brands offer even heat distribution and are compatible with various cooktops, including gas, electric, and induction stoves. They are also oven-safe and can withstand high temperatures.

One of the biggest differences between the two brands is their non-stick performance. While both claim to have excellent non-stick properties, Gotham Steel is known for its ultra non-stick claim, which may give it a slight edge. The titanium and ceramic blend in Gotham Steel cookware is designed to be more durable and long-lasting, making it a better option if you're looking for scratch resistance.

In terms of aesthetics, Gotham Steel pans are known for their signature copper colour, while Granite Rock cookware often features a black or dark grey exterior. When it comes to pricing, Granite Rock tends to be slightly more affordable than Gotham Steel.

Ultimately, the choice between the two brands may come down to personal preferences, such as budget and design. However, if you are looking for a pan that can withstand high-heat cooking, Granite Rock might be the better option, as it has a better reputation for heat retention. On the other hand, if you prioritise scratch resistance and a longer-lasting non-stick coating, Gotham Steel could be the right choice for you.

Granite Rock pans are coated with avocado oil-infused ceramic and pressed aluminium

The aluminium base of the Granite Rock pans is pressed from a single, solid disc, which allows for consistent, even heat distribution. The aluminium is then coated with three layers of the avocado oil-infused ceramic, which is said to give the pans their non-stick quality. The outer coating is also designed to look like real granite, giving the pans a stylish, rock-like appearance.

The avocado oil-infused ceramic coating is reinforced with diamonds, which are said to provide additional durability. This combination of granite and diamond flecks is also scratch-resistant and can be used with metal utensils without causing damage.

While the Granite Rock pans are advertised as non-stick, some reviews claim that food does tend to stick to the surface, especially eggs. Many reviews suggest using a small amount of oil to prevent food from sticking. The pans are also said to have metal handles that get very hot and would benefit from a rubber coating.

Overall, the Granite Rock pans seem to be a good option for those seeking a durable, non-stick cooking surface. However, it is important to note that some reviews claim that the non-stick coating may not be as effective as advertised and that additional oil or butter may be needed for optimal performance.

Gotham Steel pans are made from a blend of titanium and ceramic

The Gotham Steel pan is a non-stick cookware item made from a blend of two materials: ceramic and titanium. The titanium forms the inner core of the pan, coated with a layer of food-grade ceramics. This combination of materials creates a durable, non-stick cooking surface that is PTFE/PFOA & PFOS free.

The titanium core of the Gotham Steel pan is what sets it apart from other non-stick cookware. Titanium is a strong, lightweight metal that can withstand high temperatures. It provides a sturdy base for the ceramic coating, ensuring that the pan is durable and long-lasting.

The ceramic coating is what gives the Gotham Steel pan its non-stick properties. Ceramics are known for their smooth, non-porous surfaces, which prevent food from sticking. This makes the Gotham Steel pan easy to clean and helps to ensure that food doesn't stick, burn, or release toxic fumes, even if the pan is accidentally overheated.

The combination of titanium and ceramic also allows the Gotham Steel pan to be used with metal utensils without worrying about scratching or damaging the cooking surface. However, despite the durability of the materials, the pan is not intended for use with induction cooktops.

The design and materials of the Gotham Steel pan offer several advantages for cooks. The non-stick surface means that little to no oil or butter is needed, resulting in healthier cooking. The pan is also oven-safe up to 500°F, making it suitable for a variety of cooking methods. However, it's important to note that food may begin to stick at higher temperatures, so it's best suited for low to medium heat.

The Gotham Steel pan is a lightweight, durable, and versatile option for cooks looking for non-stick cookware. Its combination of titanium and ceramic provides a unique blend of strength and non-stick properties, making it a popular choice for those seeking an alternative to traditional cookware.

Granite Rock pans have a rough surface that requires seasoning

The rough surface of the Granite Rock pan means that food is more likely to stick to it compared to pans with a smoother surface. To prevent sticking, the Granite Rock pan requires seasoning with oil or butter before use. This process fills in the pores and creates a non-stick surface. While the Granite Rock pan is marketed as non-stick, it is important to note that it is not completely non-stick without proper seasoning.

The need for seasoning can be considered a drawback of the Granite Rock pan, as it adds an extra step to the cooking process. Additionally, the rough surface may make cleaning the pan more time-consuming, as it can be difficult to remove oil and grease. However, the rough surface also provides the benefit of exceptional durability. The combination of granite and diamond flecks creates a truly scratch-resistant surface that can withstand metal utensils without damaging the pan.

Overall, while the Granite Rock pan requires seasoning due to its rough surface, it offers a durable and scratch-resistant cooking option.

Gotham Steel pans have a smooth surface

The Gotham Steel pan has a smooth surface with a copper finish. The pan's surface is a titanium-infused ceramic "finish". The pan is coated three times and then reinforced with diamonds to deliver an ultimate food release. The Gotham Steel pan is advertised as having a non-stick surface, and reviews reflect that the pan initially lives up to this claim. However, after a few months, the non-stick coating begins to wane, and food starts to stick to the pan.

The Gotham Steel pan is lightweight and easy to manoeuvre. The pan's thin walls contribute to its lightweight nature, but also make it prone to warping and denting. The pan's handle is also thin and becomes very hot when in use, making it uncomfortable to hold.

The Gotham Steel pan is suitable for use on a mid-range electric stovetop or in the oven. It is not suitable for induction stovetops. The pan is oven-safe up to 500°F (260°C). The pan is dishwasher-safe, but handwashing will prolong the life of the non-stick coating.

Granite Rock pans are better for high-heat cooking

Gotham Steel pans are made of a titanium and ceramic blend, while Granite Rock pans are made of pressed aluminium coated with avocado oil-infused ceramic and feature pressed aluminium. The titanium core of Gotham Steel pans makes them unsuitable for ultra-high-temperature cooking over extended periods. On the other hand, Granite Rock pans are made for all-purpose versatility and are suitable for ultra-high-temperature cooking.

Gotham Steel pans are also known for their thin walls, which cause them to heat up quickly and cool down just as fast. This makes them prone to warping and scorching or burning food. Granite Rock pans, on the other hand, are made of a thicker material, making them more suitable for high-heat cooking.

While both Granite Rock and Gotham Steel pans have their pros and cons, if you're looking for a pan that can handle high-heat cooking, the Granite Rock pan is the better option.

Frequently asked questions