Hand Tossed Vs Pan: Which Pizza's Thicker?

When it comes to pizza, there are many options to choose from, but two of the most popular styles are hand-tossed and pan pizza. While both are delicious in their own right, there are some key differences between the two. So, which one is thicker?

The answer is pan pizza. Pan pizza is made by baking the dough in a cast-iron skillet or cake pan, resulting in a thick and soft crust. On the other hand, hand-tossed pizza is made by tossing and turning the dough in the air, creating a thinner and crispier crust. The dough for hand-tossed pizza is softer and thinner, as it needs to be flexible enough to toss and stretch without breaking.

In addition to thickness, there are other differences between hand-tossed and pan pizza. Pan pizza dough is denser and full of air bubbles, giving it a fluffy and bread-like texture. It also tends to have more toppings because the thicker crust can support the weight. Hand-tossed pizza, on the other hand, has fewer toppings due to its thinner crust.

So, if you're craving a thick and fluffy slice of pizza, go for the pan pizza. But if you prefer a thinner and crispier option, hand-tossed is the way to go.

Preparation: Hand-tossed pizza is made by tossing the dough in the air, while pan pizza is made by spreading the dough in a pan

Hand-Tossed Pizza Preparation

To make a hand-tossed pizza, you need to prepare the dough as you normally would. Once the dough is ready, you round it and spread it into a smaller circle with the help of your fingertips. You then need to apply pressure around the perimeter of the dough to form a thick crust. Once you have a firm structure of a small-sized pizza crust, you prepare to toss it. Sprinkle some flour on the dough and your workstation. Hold the dough with your dominant hand as if you are holding a dinner plate. Start tossing the dough in a counter-clockwise direction. Once the dough starts rotating, gently lift it so it can toss itself around and fall back into your hand. Repeat these steps until you have your desired shape. Once the dough is ready, place it on a pizza peel, add your toppings and sauce, and bake.

Pan Pizza Preparation

To make a pan pizza, you need to prepare the dough as you would normally. You can use any type of oven-safe pan, such as a cast-iron skillet, cake pan, or pie dish. Prepare the pan by greasing it with oil. Spread the dough around the pan, making sure the edges touch the walls of the pan. This ensures that the thick crust cooks evenly. Add your desired toppings and bake in the oven.

Crust: Hand-tossed pizza has a thin, crispy crust, while pan pizza has a thick, chewy crust

Crust is one of the most significant differences between hand-tossed and pan pizza. The preparation techniques for these two pizza styles vary, resulting in distinct crust textures and thicknesses.

Hand-tossed pizza is characterised by a thin, crispy crust. This is achieved by tossing and turning the dough in the air, which removes air bubbles and prevents the dough from rising significantly during baking. The dough is then baked on a slab or pizza stone, resulting in a dry, blistered, and crunchy crust.

On the other hand, pan pizza boasts a thick, chewy crust. This is created by baking the pizza in a pan, such as a cast-iron skillet or cake pan, which restricts the dough's expansion. The dough rises and creates a thick crust due to the retention of air bubbles. The crust of a pan pizza is often compared to focaccia, with a soft and fluffy texture.

The hand-tossing technique for hand-tossed pizza requires skill and practice. The dough is tossed and turned in the air until it forms a circular shape, which is then baked. This process removes air bubbles and results in a thin, crispy crust. In contrast, preparing a pan pizza is relatively simple and does not require any special equipment. The dough is shaped and baked in a pan, resulting in a thick and chewy crust.

The crust of a hand-tossed pizza is thinner and crispier, making it suitable for those who prefer a classic, lighter pizza. The pan pizza's crust, on the other hand, is thicker and chewier, resembling fried bread. This makes it a good choice for those who enjoy a hearty, indulgent pizza experience.

While the crusts differ significantly, both hand-tossed and pan pizzas offer a delightful crunch. The choice between the two ultimately depends on personal preference for crust thickness and texture.

Texture: Hand-tossed pizza dough is soft, while pan pizza dough is bread-like and fluffy

The texture of a pizza base is an important factor in determining how the pizza will taste. Hand-tossed pizza dough and pan pizza dough have distinct textures, which influence the overall character of the pizza.

Hand-tossed pizza dough is known for its soft and chewy texture. The dough is stretched and shaped by hand, creating a thin and even crust. This process also forms air pockets in the dough, which contribute to the crust's texture and flavour. The dough is made using high-gluten flour, water, salt, and yeast, resulting in a light and crispy base. This type of dough is ideal for those who prefer a thinner and crispier crust with just the right amount of chewiness.

On the other hand, pan pizza dough has a bread-like and fluffy texture. It is baked in a deep dish, resulting in a thicker and doughier crust. The dough is typically made with all-purpose flour, water, salt, and yeast, and it is baked in a pan or cast-iron skillet. This method produces a crust that is crispy on the outside and soft on the inside. The use of a pan allows the crust to be baked evenly, creating a caramelized exterior and a soft interior that can hold plenty of toppings. The dough is usually made with high-gluten flour, giving it the structure needed to hold heavier toppings.

The difference in textures between hand-tossed and pan pizza doughs is mainly due to the preparation methods and the type of flour used. Hand-tossed dough is stretched and tossed by hand, creating a thinner and lighter crust. In contrast, pan pizza dough is baked in a pan, resulting in a thicker and fluffier base. The type of flour also plays a role, with hand-tossed dough using high-gluten flour and pan pizza dough using all-purpose flour.

The texture of the pizza base not only affects the taste but also the overall dining experience. Hand-tossed pizza, with its thinner and crispier crust, is often preferred by those who enjoy the authenticity and traditional Italian style of pizza. It is also a good option for those who want a lighter meal or prefer their pizza without cutlery. On the other hand, pan pizza, with its thicker and fluffier crust, is perfect for those who like a hearty and filling slice. The soft and pillowy texture of the crust makes it ideal for those who enjoy overloaded pizzas with rich sauces and heavy toppings.

In summary, the texture of hand-tossed pizza dough is soft and chewy, while pan pizza dough has a bread-like and fluffy texture. These differences in texture ultimately contribute to the unique characteristics and appeal of each pizza style.

Toppings: Pan pizza can hold more toppings than hand-tossed pizza due to its thicker crust

When it comes to pizza, the possibilities for toppings are endless. However, the type of pizza you choose may determine how many toppings you can pile on. In the debate between hand-tossed and pan pizza, pan pizza typically wins out when it comes to holding more toppings.

Pan pizza has a thicker and softer crust compared to hand-tossed pizza. The thicker crust of a pan pizza provides a sturdy base that can support a heavier load of toppings. This means you can be generous with your sauce, cheese, and other toppings without worrying about overloading the pizza. On the other hand, hand-tossed pizza has a thinner and crispier crust, which means it can't handle as many toppings. If you overload a hand-tossed pizza, the crust might struggle to bear the weight.

The thicker crust of a pan pizza also allows for more cheese. While a hand-tossed pizza typically uses just one type of cheese, such as mozzarella, a pan pizza can accommodate a variety of cheeses, such as mozzarella, white cheddar, and fontina. The extra cheese adds to the overall flavour and texture of the pan pizza.

In addition to cheese, pan pizzas are often loaded with sauce and a variety of toppings. Popular choices include vegetables like mushrooms, peppers, onions, and tomatoes, as well as meats like pepperoni, sausage, and chicken. With its thicker crust, a pan pizza can handle these heavier toppings without sacrificing taste or texture.

The versatility of pan pizza doesn't end with the toppings. You can also get creative with the type of pan you use. While a traditional circular pan is common, you can also use a rectangular sheet tray, similar to a Sicilian pizza, or even a cast-iron skillet. This flexibility allows you to make a pan pizza that fits your unique preferences.

Whether you're a fan of meat lovers' pizza or prefer a vegetarian option, pan pizza is a great choice if you want to load up on toppings. So, the next time you're deciding between hand-tossed and pan pizza, consider how many toppings you want and choose accordingly!

Taste: Pan pizza tends to taste cheesier and oilier than hand-tossed pizza

Pan pizzas tend to taste cheesier and oilier than hand-tossed pizzas. This is due to the way they are prepared and cooked, as well as the types of ingredients used.

Firstly, pan pizzas are cooked in olive oil, which gives them a crispy, flaky crust. The dough is spread out in a pan greased with olive oil, and the crust is often coated in oil, resulting in a crisp exterior and a soft, chewy interior. On the other hand, hand-tossed pizzas are cooked on a pizza stone or baking sheet, and while they may also have a crispy crust, it is drier and less greasy.

Secondly, pan pizzas are usually loaded with more cheese than hand-tossed pizzas. The thicker crust of a pan pizza provides more support for heavier toppings, and the way the toppings are layered in a pan pizza results in a cheesier texture. Pan pizzas are also baked at a higher temperature than hand-tossed pizzas, which contributes to the melted, gooey cheese characteristic of this style.

Thirdly, the dough used for pan pizzas is denser and contains more dough, resulting in a fluffier texture. The dough rises a lot during baking because the air bubbles in the dough stay intact. In contrast, the act of tossing and stretching hand-tossed pizza dough by hand results in a thinner, crispier crust that has lost some of its air bubbles and doesn't rise as much.

Finally, the overall taste and experience of eating a pan pizza versus a hand-tossed pizza differ. Pan pizzas are super hearty and filling, with a thick and fluffy crust that can handle heavier toppings. Hand-tossed pizzas, on the other hand, have a lighter and drier taste, with a thin and crispy crust that showcases the toppings.

Frequently asked questions