Butter Or Oil For Steak: Which Is Better?

When it comes to cooking the perfect steak, one of the most important considerations is the choice of cooking fat or oil. The ideal option depends on the cooking temperature and the desired taste. Butter has a low smoke point, so it's not suitable for high-heat cooking methods like searing or grilling as it will burn. On the other hand, oils like avocado, rice bran, and soybean have high smoke points, making them better choices for achieving a good sear without compromising the flavour. However, some chefs and steak enthusiasts swear by using butter for that irresistible buttery taste. To get the best of both worlds, one can cook the steak with oil and then finish it off with a generous topping of butter, allowing it to melt and caramelize over the steak.

Butter has a low smoke point, so it burns at high heat

When cooking steak, it is important to consider the smoke point of your cooking fat of choice. The smoke point is the temperature at which cooking fats, such as oil, butter, or lard, start to smoke. Using a fat with a high smoke point is crucial when cooking at high temperatures, such as when searing a steak, as fats can break down and degrade at high heat, impacting their flavour, aroma, and nutrition.

Butter has a relatively low smoke point, typically between 300 and 350 degrees Fahrenheit. This means that if you heat a pan to a high temperature to sear a steak, the butter is likely to burn, giving your food a bitter and burnt taste. The milk solids in butter burn quickly and can negatively affect the flavour of your dish.

To avoid this issue, it is recommended to use a cooking fat with a higher smoke point, such as oil, for searing steaks. Oils like canola, olive, coconut, and avocado oil have smoke points ranging from 400 to 520 degrees Fahrenheit, making them better suited for high-heat cooking.

However, this doesn't mean you have to miss out on the delicious flavour that butter adds to a steak. Instead of using butter as your cooking fat, try using it as a finishing oil. After your steak is cooked, place a pat of butter on top and allow it to melt, adding a rich, buttery taste to your steak. Alternatively, you can use clarified butter or ghee, which have higher smoke points than regular butter due to the removal of water and milk solids, making them suitable for higher-heat cooking.

Oils with high smoke points include avocado, rice bran and soybean

When cooking steak, the choice of cooking fat depends on the cooking temperature. This is because the smoke point of butter or oil matters: you don't want burnt butter or oil flavouring your food or making your pan harder to clean.

Butter has a smoke point of just over 300°F. This means that if you heat up a pan hot enough to sear your steak, putting butter in first means it will likely burn. However, you can still get the delicious flavour of butter with your steak by using it as a finishing oil. After your steak's final flip, place a pat of butter on top and allow it to melt and caramelise.

If you are cooking steak, oils with high smoke points are recommended. Oils with high smoke points include avocado oil (refined), which has a smoke point of 480-520°F; rice bran oil, which has a nice sweetness and a high smoke point; and soybean oil, which is high in monounsaturated and polyunsaturated fats.

Olive oil has a low smoke point and a strong taste

When cooking steak, the choice of cooking fat depends on the desired cooking temperature. The smoke point of the chosen oil or butter is important because heating it above this temperature will cause it to burn, affecting the flavor of the food and making the pan harder to clean.

Olive oil has a relatively low smoke point, typically ranging between 350°F and 410°F, though it can be as high as 470°F. This is lower than the smoke point of some other oils, such as avocado oil, which has a smoke point of 520°F, and coconut oil, which has a smoke point of 450°F.

The low smoke point of olive oil means that it may not be suitable for cooking steak at high temperatures. If the oil reaches its smoke point during cooking, it can affect the flavor of the dish. While olive oil has a distinct taste, it can add an undesirable flavor to the steak if it burns.

However, the impact of using olive oil on the taste of the steak may not be significant, especially if the steak is served with other ingredients, such as a sauce. In addition, olive oil is rich in oleic acid and contains minor compounds that make it stable at high temperatures. Studies have shown that olive oil holds up well under high-heat conditions and may even be one of the more stable oils for high-heat cooking.

In conclusion, while olive oil has a low smoke point and a strong taste, it may still be suitable for cooking steak depending on the desired cooking temperature and the presence of other ingredients that could mask any undesirable flavors.

Clarified butter has a higher smoke point than regular butter

When cooking steak, the choice of cooking fat depends on the temperature required. The smoke point of the fat is important because heating oil or butter beyond their smoke point will cause them to burn, affecting the flavour of the food and making the pan harder to clean. Butter has a smoke point of around 300°F, while oils have a much higher smoke point, with avocado oil reaching 520°F. This means that if you heat a pan to sear a steak, putting butter in first will likely cause it to burn.

However, clarified butter has a much higher smoke point than regular butter, so it can be used to cook steak without burning. Regular butter is an emulsion of about 80% fat and 15% water, with the remainder made up of milk proteins. These milk proteins are the reason that butter burns at a lower temperature than oil. Clarified butter is butter from which all milk solids and water have been removed, leaving almost 100% butterfat. This means it can be heated to a much higher temperature before burning. Clarified butter has a smoke point of around 450°F to 486°F, compared to 350°F to 376°F for regular butter. This makes it ideal for cooking applications such as sautéing and searing steak. It also has a longer shelf life than fresh butter and a slightly more subdued butter flavour.

To make clarified butter, you melt butter and remove the milk solids and water, leaving only the butterfat. This can be done by melting butter and skimming the foamy milk solids from the surface, then ladling off the pure butterfat. Alternatively, you can boil off the water completely and strain the browned milk solids at the end. This method, commonly used to make ghee (Indian clarified butter), gives the finished product a subtle nutty flavour.

A little oil helps the pan conduct heat better

When cooking steak, you want to achieve a beautiful sear without compromising the flavor. To do this, you need to consider the smoke point of the fat or oil you're using. The smoke point is the temperature at which the fat or oil begins to break down and smoke, which can fill your kitchen with blue, noxious smoke and leave your steak tasting strange.

While butter adds a delicious flavor to your steak, it has a low smoke point of just over 300°F, which means it will burn at the high heat required for searing steak. To avoid this, you can use clarified butter, which has had the milk solids removed, raising its smoke point to 450°F. However, even with clarified butter, you still need to be careful not to burn it.

Oils with high smoke points are better options for searing steak. These oils can handle the high heat without burning and provide a beautiful sear. Avocado oil, in particular, has a high smoke point of 480°F or higher and is flavorless, so it won't overpower the taste of your steak.

However, a little oil can go a long way. Drizzling just a small amount of oil on the cooking surface can help the pan conduct heat better and give your steak even browning. This is important because browning is where the flavor is. When the steak's surface gets crispy and golden brown, it creates delicious compounds through the Maillard reaction, resulting in a rich, meaty taste and aroma.

So, while you don't need to use a lot of oil, adding a small amount can improve the heat conduction of your pan and enhance the flavor of your steak. Just be sure to choose an oil with a high smoke point to avoid burning and affecting the taste of your steak.

Frequently asked questions