Time To Toss Your Non-Stick Pan: Signs To Watch For

Non-stick pans are convenient, but they don't last forever. The non-stick coating will eventually wear out, and the pan will need to be replaced. This lifespan varies depending on how well you care for your pan and the type of non-stick coating. Here are some telltale signs that it's time to get rid of your non-stick pan:

- Dark discolouration caused by burning or residue buildup.

- Deep scratches on the surface that cut through the coating down to the metal.

- Peeling, flaking, or chipping of the non-stick coating.

- Warping, which can result in an uneven cooking surface.

- Food starts to stick to the pan, even after seasoning it with oil.

Dark discolouration

You can remove these types of persistent stains with a thorough cleaning. Fill the pan halfway with water and a little washing-up liquid, then bring it to a boil. The cooking process should remove the charred residue. If this doesn't work, you can use a melamine sponge with some water to remove the carbonisation.

However, if your pan has become darkly discoloured, it's probably time to replace it. Non-stick pans have a limited lifespan due to their delicate non-stick coating, and dark discolouration is a strong indicator that this coating is wearing out.

Scratches

Non-stick pans manufactured before 2013/2014 used a hazardous man-made chemical called Perfluorooctanoic acid (PFOA). PFOAs were proven to contain cancer-causing chemicals. If your pan is scratched, the non-stick surface has been compromised and these chemicals could be flaking off into your food.

Even if your pan is newer and doesn't contain PFOAs, scratches can still impact the effectiveness of the non-stick coating. Scratches, high heat, and general wear and tear will wear down the slick coating on the surface of your pan.

To prevent scratches, make sure you use non-stick-friendly utensils such as wooden or silicone spoons and spatulas. Avoid metal utensils, which can scratch the surface. When cleaning, avoid abrasive sponges such as steel wool, and instead use soft-sided sponges to avoid accidental scratching. When storing your pans, place a cloth towel over the surface to prevent scratches from stacked pans.

Peeling, flaking, chipping

Peeling, flaking, or chipping non-stick pans are a safety hazard and should be replaced. While non-stick coatings are usually not harmful to health, ingesting foreign substances that are not edible is never a good idea.

The non-stick coating on a pan will wear off over time, and once it starts to peel, chip, or flake, it will only continue to do so. This will contribute to the loss of its non-stick quality. Deep scratches on the surface of a non-stick pan likely mean that the coating has been compromised, and this will only get worse over time.

To prevent scratches, it is recommended to use non-stick-safe utensils such as wooden or silicone tools. It is also important to clean according to the manufacturer's recommendations and store the pan carefully.

While a non-stick pan with a worn-out coating is usually still usable, it may require the addition of more oil or butter during cooking as long as the coating remains intact. However, if the coating is compromised, it is best to replace the pan.

Non-stick pans should be replaced approximately every three to five years, depending on their condition.

Warped

Pans warp primarily due to rapid temperature changes. Placing a hot pan under cold running water or putting it away in a sink with water can cause this. Additionally, heating an empty pan over high heat for an extended period can lead to warping. The heat causes the metal to expand and contract at different rates, resulting in thermal breakage. Using a burner that is too small for your pan can also cause concentrated heat in the centre, leading to warping.

The quality of your pan also plays a role. Thinner pans are more susceptible to warping than thicker ones, and cheaper pans made from softer metals like aluminium are more prone to warping than those made from heavier metals like stainless steel.

Fixing Warped Pans

While warped pans can be annoying, they can often be fixed. Here are some methods to try:

• Pound flat with a hammer: Place a towel on a flat, durable surface. Set the pan on the towel and cover with another towel. Pound the warped area with a hammer until it is flattened.
• Use a wooden block: For severely warped pans, use a wooden block and a hammer. Place the pan on a towel-covered flat surface and put the wooden block on the warped area. Hammer the block to distribute the force evenly and flatten the pan.
• Use a mallet and a piece of wood: Warm the pan on low heat for 5-10 minutes. Place it on a flat, heat-resistant surface, and put a piece of wood along the warped side. Tap the wood with a mallet until the pan is flattened.

Preventing Warping

To prevent warping, avoid exposing your pans to rapid temperature changes. Allow them to cool gradually before washing and avoid placing hot pans under cold running water. When using the oven, ensure your pans are at least at room temperature before placing them inside. Additionally, choose high-quality pans made from durable materials like stainless steel or cast iron.

Sticking

Non-stick pans are convenient for cooking and cleaning, but they don't last forever. Here are some signs that indicate it's time to get rid of your non-stick pan:

Warping

Warping can occur when a pan is heated to high temperatures and then rapidly cooled, such as when cooking eggs and then immediately placing the pan in the sink with soap and water. This results in an uneven cooking surface, compromising the quality of your food. While warping doesn't necessarily pose a health risk, it can affect the taste and texture of your dishes.

Discoloration

Dark discoloration on your non-stick pan is usually caused by burning or the buildup of residue. While light discoloration is common and not an issue, deep discoloration indicates that the non-stick coating is wearing out. To prevent excessive discoloration, clean your pan immediately after use, stick to medium-low heat, and avoid storing food in the pan.

Scratches

Scratches on the surface of a non-stick pan can compromise the coating, leading to potential health risks. Older pans manufactured before 2013 may contain hazardous chemicals like Perfluorooctanoic acid (PFOA), which has been linked to cancer. To prevent scratches, use non-stick-safe utensils like wooden or silicone tools, clean according to the manufacturer's instructions, and store your pan carefully to avoid stacking or abrasion.

Peeling, Flaking, and Chipping

If the non-stick coating starts to peel, chip, or flake, it's a clear sign that your pan needs to be replaced. Once the coating begins to deteriorate, it will continue to do so, affecting the non-stick quality. While these coatings are generally not harmful, ingesting foreign substances can be unpleasant and undesirable.

If food starts sticking to your non-stick pan, it's a sign that the coating may be wearing off. Try seasoning the pan by warming it over low heat and rubbing a neutral oil like canola oil all over the interior. If sticking persists, it's time to invest in a new pan.

Frequently asked questions