Copper Pans: Safe Or Not?

Copper pans are reactive and toxic when ingested, so they are unsafe to cook with. However, copper pans lined with tin are safe to cook with, as the tin creates a non-reactive barrier between the copper and the food. Tin is non-toxic and safe for use with food and drink. Nevertheless, it is important to note that the safety of tin-lined copper cookware depends on the quality of the tin lining. If the tin coating is scratched, worn, or damaged, it can expose the copper underneath and potentially lead to copper leaching into food.

Tin is safe to consume in small quantities

Tin is widely used as a lining for copper cookware, providing a non-toxic barrier between food and the copper pan. Tin is a soft metal, and it wears away over time, especially with frequent cooking, scraping, and cleaning. This means that some tin particles may end up in your food. However, scientific research confirms that ingesting small amounts of tin is safe.

Tin has no known biological role in living organisms, and it is not easily absorbed by animals or humans. Most ingested tin passes through the body without being absorbed, exiting in faeces or urine. The US Center for Disease Control's Public Health Statement for Tin confirms that:

> "When you eat tin in your food, very little leaves the gastrointestinal tract and gets into your bloodstream. Most tin travels through the intestines and leaves your body in the feces. Some leaves your body in the urine... If you swallow some metallic tin particles, they will leave your body in the feces... Your body can rid itself of most inorganic tin in weeks, but some can stay in your body for 2-3 months. Inorganic tin compounds leave your body very quickly; most are gone within a day."

Tin poisoning is extremely rare, and according to G. G. Graf, "Cases of poisoning from tin metal, its oxides, and its salts are almost unknown." However, ingesting large amounts of inorganic tin can cause negative side effects, including stomachaches, anaemia, and liver and kidney problems.

The risk of tin poisoning from cookware is minimal, and the widespread use of tin in cookware and canned food attests to its safety. Tin has been used for centuries in cookware, and multiple scientific authorities continue to endorse its use. Therefore, while it is important to be aware of the potential risks of any substance, you can rest assured that the small quantities of tin that may end up in your food from your copper pans are safe to consume.

Tin is a non-stick material

Tin is a relatively soft metal with a low melting point. It is used as a lining in copper cookware because it is non-toxic, non-reactive, and resists corrosion. While tin is not toxic in small amounts, it is not a non-stick material. In fact, tin is fragile and can be scratched easily, even by a fingernail. Tin also has a low melting point, so it is possible to accidentally melt your tin pan if left on the heat for too long.

Tin is mostly non-reactive, but it is not entirely so. According to scientific research, when tin wears away, some of it could end up in your food. However, this is not harmful unless consumed in high quantities. The US Center for Disease Control's Public Health Statement for Tin explains that when you eat tin in your food, very little enters the bloodstream. Most tin passes through the body without being absorbed.

Tin is a chemical element with the symbol Sn (from Latin stannum) and the atomic number 50. It is a silvery-coloured metal that is soft enough to be cut with little force. Tin is obtained chiefly from the mineral cassiterite, which contains stannic oxide, SnO2. It is one of the easiest elements to detect and analyse by NMR spectroscopy.

Tin has been used for cookware linings for a long time. It is also used for food packaging, such as "tin cans", due to its low toxicity. Tin is alloyed with copper to make bronze, which has been used since around 3000 BC.

Tin is a softer metal than copper

Tin has a Brinell hardness of around 27, while copper has a Brinell hardness of around 40-50. This means that copper is harder than tin and will take more force to deform.

The reason that tin is often used to line copper cookware is that it is safe for use with food and drink. Tin is non-toxic, and even if small amounts are ingested, the body can rid itself of most inorganic tin within weeks. In addition, tin does not easily absorb into the body, so there is little risk of poisoning.

While copper is a highly conductive material that heats up and cools down quickly, it is also a reactive metal. When exposed to oxygen or acidic foods, copper can break down and leach into food, contaminating it. Ingesting copper can be toxic and lead to copper toxicity or copper poisoning.

To prevent this, copper cookware is often lined with non-reactive, food-safe metals like stainless steel or tin. This creates a barrier between the food and the copper, preventing leaching and protecting against copper poisoning. However, if the lining of a copper pan becomes scratched, dinged, or otherwise damaged, it is no longer safe to use.

Tin can react with acidic foods

Tin is a relatively soft metal that is safe to use for food packaging and containers. It is a non-toxic chemical element that is not easily absorbed by animals and humans. However, it is important to note that tin can react with acidic foods.

Acidic foods, such as tomato sauce, vinegar, and citrus fruits and their juices, can sometimes react with metals like tin and aluminum. While this reaction does not make the food unsafe to eat, it can cause discoloration and the formation of small holes in the metal. The acid causes the metal to break down into a salt, which is harmless and safe to consume.

The same reaction can occur when using tin-lined copper cookware. The acid in foods can cause the release of metals, including tin, from the cookware into the food. This leaching of metals is more prominent at lower pH levels and higher temperatures. For example, a study found that boiling temperatures resulted in a much higher migration of metals compared to cold storage.

To avoid reactions between acidic foods and tin, it is recommended to use a thin coating of oil on the tin surface before adding the food. Additionally, for food storage, plastic wrap can be used instead of direct contact with tin foil.

While tin is generally safe for food use, it is important to be cautious when using it with acidic foods to prevent any unwanted reactions or discoloration.

Copper pans are highly conductive

A copper pan distributes an even temperature over the bottom and sides, allowing food to cook evenly. This gives the cook more control over temperature and subtle changes in heat and intensity can be achieved. Copper pans are therefore perfect for creating delicate sauces, such as hollandaise, or for melting chocolate.

The high conductivity of copper pans also means that they can be used for quick sauté dishes. This makes them a popular choice for professional chefs and discerning cooks.

However, copper is a reactive metal and can leach into food when exposed to acidic foods like tomatoes or citrus fruits. To prevent this, copper pans are often lined with a thin layer of non-toxic tin or stainless steel. Tin is a relatively soft metal and will wear away over time, so copper pans with tin linings should be treated with care.

Frequently asked questions